Monday, March 5, 2012

Why critics of Rails have it all wrong (and Ruby's bright multicore future)

Edit: Contrary to what I said here, José Valim is not stepping down from Rails core, he is merely on sabbatical. My bad.

Lately I've been getting the feeling the Ruby community has gotten a bit emo. The enthusiasm surrounding how easy Ruby makes it to write clean, concise, well-tested web applications quickly is fading. Rails has become merely a day job for many. Whatever hype surrounded Rails at its inception has died down into people who are just getting work done.

Meanwhile, Node.js is the new hotness, and many in the Node community have sought to build Node up by bringing Ruby and Rails down. I know that once upon a time Ruby enthusiasts were doing this sort of thing to Java. However, the tables have turned, and where Ruby used to be the mudslinging hype-monkey, it's now become the whipping boy and Node.js the new provocateur.

The sad thing is many of these people are former or current Rubyists who have taken a liking to Node and build it up by spreading blatant untruths about Ruby. I won't go as far as to call them liars, but at the very least, they are extremely misinformed, ignorant of the state of the Ruby ecosystem, and pushing their own agendas.

Jeremy Ashkenas, the creator of CoffeeScript, recently trashed Rails 3 and claimed "Node.js won":

The idea that Rails 3 was a major step backward was recently reiterated by both Giles Bowkett and Matt Aimonetti. Both of them painted building ActionController::Metal applications as some sort of byzantine, impossible task which can only be accomplished by a Rails core member. Are people actually building lightweight Rails applications using the newfound modularity of Rails 3?

Jose Valim, (now former) Rails core member, published a small, simple gist illustrating how to build barebones apps on ActionController::Metal (one of the most forked gists I've ever seen) which is further documented in his book Crafting Rails Applications. In just 50 lines of code you can strip Rails down to its core, making it ideal for use in modern client-heavy HTML5 applications. The funny thing about this gist is that while the idea of a 50 line Rails app seems pretty impressive, the basis of that gist is what Rails 3 puts into your config/boot.rb, environment.rb, and application.rb, just combined into a single file. Did I just blow your mind? Sadly, all the (in my opinion completely undeserved) bad press seems to have made Jose emo as well, and he has stepped down from Rails to pursue his Elixir language.

ActionController::Metal-based applications (along with apps written in Clojure) were the basis of our backend at Strobe, where we sought to ease the pains of people building modern client-heavy HTML5/JS applications with frameworks including SproutCore/Ember, Backbone, and Spine. ActionController::Metal provided a great, fully-featured, mature, and modular platform for us to build applications on top of, and Strobe's ActionController::Metal stack for client-heavy HTML5/JS applications is available on Github. The apps we built with the Strobe ActionController::Metal stack talked only JSON and our frontend was an HTML5/JS application written with SproutCore.

Before Strobe, I worked at a company building rich HTML/JS applications for digital television. Our backend was written in Rails. Our frontends were Flash and HTML/JS applications, the latter of which were single-page client-heavy HTML/JS apps that were packaged in .zip files and installed onto digital televisions and set top boxes, a sort of weird hybrid of web technologies and installable applications. Our Rails application didn't have any views, but provided only a JSON API for the HTML/JS frontend to consume.

Rails was great for this, because it provided the sort of high level abstractions we needed in order to be productive, ensure our application was well-tested, and above all else provided the necessary foundation for clean, maintainable code. I was doing this in 2008, and even then this was already considered old hat in the Rails community. In case you're not paying attention, that's one year before Node even existed.

Modern HTML5/JS apps depend on beautiful, consistent RESTful JSON APIs. This is a great way to develop rich interactive applications, because it separates the concerns of what the backend business logic is doing from the view layer entirely. Separate teams, each specialized in their role, can develop the frontend and backend independently, the frontend people concerned with creating a great user experience, and the backend people concerned with building a great API the frontend application can consume.

Rails is great for JSON APIs.

And yet this meme persists, that somehow Rails is actually bad at JSON APIs. Those who propagate this meme insist that Rails has lost its edge, and that only Node understands the needs of these sorts of modern client-heavy web applications. Giles recently attempted to argue this position:

Giles recently blogged about this issue at length. Let's look at what he has to say about ActionController::Metal and the new level of modularity and clean design that Rails 3 brings to the table:

So Jose wrote a great book about the incredible power of Rails 3's new modular APIs... but... but... but what?


Hurrrrrrrr? Ward Cunningham is a cool guy and his concept of a Wiki was a transformative technology for the web, but what the fuck does that have to do with Rails 3's new modular APIs or Jose's book? I think that's what people in logical debate circles call a "non-sequitur".

Perhaps there's still a cogent argument to be had here. Let's dig deeper:

Okay, so the problem is there's not a damn simple way to do websockets. OH WAIT, THERE IS:

Cramp is an awesome, easy-to-use websockets/server-sent events framework (with support) which runs on Rainbows or Thin, and Thin is a great web server. According to my benchmarks it's approximately the same speed as Node's web server:

Web Server            Throughput  Latency
----------            ----------  -------
Thin    (1.2.11)      8747 reqs/s (7.3 ms/req)
Node.js (0.6.5)       9023 reqs/s (7.1 ms/req)
Yes folks, Node isn't significantly faster than Ruby at web server performance. They're about the same.

Giles also bemoans bundler, because typing "bundle exec" represents ceremony, and using any of the myriad solutions to avoid typing "bundle exec", such as bundler binstubs or rvm gemsets, represents configuration which violates the Rails mantra of "convention over configuration", and how npm is that much easier. I'm sure we would all love to not have to add a one line .rvmrc file to each project to avoid typing "bundle exec", but uhh Giles, bro, mountain out of a molehill much?

Meanwhile, let's check out how convention over configuration is going in the JavaScript world:

But enough about Giles... what kinds of awesome, modern HTML5 applications are people using Rails to build?

I think one of the best examples of this sort of application is Travis CI. Travis is an open source distributed build system with an Ember-based frontend and a Rails backend. Travis's interface shows, in real time, the state of all builds across the entire (distributed) system, allows you to interactively explore the history, see the distributed build matrix completing jobs in realtime, and even have it stream the console output of builds in progress directly to your browser as they complete. It's an amazing, modern client-heavy HTML5/JS application, and it's built on Rails.

Who else is using Ruby/Rails for their frontend? Oh, just Twitter, LivingSocial, Groupon, Heroku, EngineYard, Github, Square, Zendesk, Shopify, Yammer, Braintree, Boundary, Stripe, Parse, Simple, and of course let's not forget 37signals. Rails is the technology underlying the frontend web stack of many huge businesses. Many of these companies have client-heavy HTML5/JS applications which consume a JSON API coming out of Rails. Many of them have APIs that are routinely cited as archetypical RESTful JSON APIs. Many of them have top notch engineering teams that choose the best tools for the job and use many languages for many different tasks. Many of them were founded "post-Node" and had the opportunity to choose Node as their frontend web technology, and while they may use Node in some capacity, their main consumer-facing sites are written with Rails.

Node is three years old now. Where are the Node.js success stories? Who's built a brand on top of Node?  Nodejitsu? Hubot? Is Node anything more than a pyramid scheme or a platform for Campfire bots? Where Rails selling points eschewed performance and instead focused on clear code, rapid development, extensive testing, and quick time-to-market, Node's selling points seem to universally revolve around its insanely fast, destroy the internet fast performance (benchmarks not provided). Meanwhile code quality is de-emphasized and large Node programs degrade into incomprehensible, byzantine structures of callbacks and flow-control libraries, instead of being written in sequential code, you know, the code you can read:


What about Ruby in general? What advancements in the Ruby ecosystem are worth getting excited about?

JRuby is maturing into a high-performance Ruby implementation which taps the JVM's advanced features including the HotSpot compiler, multiple pluggable garbage collectors, and parallel multithreading which makes it suitable for multicore applications. One thing I think sets JRuby apart is that it's the most mature language on the JVM which didn't start there. Other projects to implement non-JVM languages on top of the JVM, such as Rhino and Jython, have languished, while JRuby keeps going strong.

The most exciting development in JRuby is Java 7's new InvokeDynamic feature. The Java Virtual Machine was originally designed for the statically-typed Java language, but has its roots in dynamic languages, namely Smalltalk. With InvokeDynamic, the JVM has come full circle and now natively supports dynamic languages like Ruby. InvokeDynamic provides the necessary information to the JVM's HotSpot compiler to generate clean native code whenever Ruby methods are called, in addition to many other potential optimizations. So how much faster will InvokeDynamic make Ruby?

Rubinius, a clean-room Ruby virtual machine based on the Smalltalk-80 architecture, is also a very exciting prospect for the Ruby community as it matures and reaches production quality. It features an LLVM-based JIT compiler, parallel thread execution, and advanced garbage collection, also making it suitable for multicore applications. Beyond being an awesome Ruby implementation, Rubinius has evolved into a true polyglot platform and now features multiple Rubinius-specific language implementations including Fancy and Atomy.

MacRuby also eliminated the GIL from their implementation and now supports parallel thread execution along with an LLVM-based JIT compiler.

There are no less than three Ruby implementations which now support thread-level parallelism and thus multicore CPUs. This is especially relevant in a time when computing is undergoing a sort of phase transition from single-threaded sequential applications to massively multithreaded concurrent applications and distributed systems made out of these multithreaded applications.

It wasn't too long ago that having even four CPU cores in your home computer seemed like a lot, and now 16-core commodity AMD CPUs are available. The future is multicore, and if your programming language doesn't have a multicore strategy, its usefulness is vanishing. Following Moore's Law, the number of cores in a CPU is set to explode exponentially. Is your programming language prepared?

Thanks to JRuby and Rubinius, Ruby can take advantage of multicore CPUs. This still leaves the small matter that multithreaded programming is, uhh, hard. Fortunately I have some ideas about that.

Celluloid is an actor-based concurrent object system that tries to pick up on the concurrent object research that was hot in the mid-90's but died shortly after the web gained popularity. In the '90s concurrent objects were ahead of their time, but with the advent of massively multicore CPUs I believe it's an area of computer science research that's worth reviving.

Celluloid packages up Ruby's core concurrency features into a simple, easy-to-use package that doesn't require any modifications to the language. Where many functional languages solve the issues surrounding concurrency with immutable state, Celluloid solves it with encapsulation (more information is available on the Celluloid github page).

Celluloid takes advantage of many of the features of Ruby, including parallel threads, fibers (coroutines), method_missing (proxy objects), and duck typing. There aren't many other languages with this particular mix of features. Python probably comes the closest, aside from multicore execution due to its GIL. Jython supports parallel thread execution thanks to the JVM but seems abandoned. For what it's worth, Python once had a concurrent object system quite similar to Celluloid back in the '90s called ATOM, unfortunately the source code has been lost.

Ruby is by far the best language available today to implement a system like Celluloid, and that alone makes me excited to be a Rubyist. Where Node.js gives you a hammer, the single-threaded event loop, Celluloid gives you a large toolbox and provides a singular framework of interoperable components which can be used to build arbitrary hybrids of concurrent multithreaded applications, event-based nonblocking applications (that are callback-free!), and distributed systems.

Ruby is a language which can survive the massively multicore future. Whether Node will stick around remains to be seen.


Anonymous said...

Great write up.

Who's built a brand on top of Node? is truly the only thing that matters in the end.

konsi said...

Great post. I didn't know about cramp before.

Stevan Little said...

I think this is just the ebbs and flows of our fashion driven industry. If you substitute "Perl" for "Ruby" and "Node.js" for "Ruby" in first three paragraphs, this echoes much of what was going on 5 years ago in those communities. Meanwhile the Perl community is still here and flourishing as Perl approaches its 25th year.

... said...

Excelent write-up! This exodus of Rubysts to node.js is actually a good thing. Now that the hype is leaving Ruby's side it will be easier for it to grow and mature as a language and platform.

... said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
... said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
... said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Caio Tiago said...

Hey, I love Ruby but I have something to show you.

Google for: Erlang concurrency

Well, you can also search for scala concurrency or smalltalk concurrency.

Ruby is not the only language with actors concurrency out there.

Tony said...

Yeah, I'm familiar with Erlang:

Celso_ said...

Caio, he's didn't say Ruby was the only whom implements Actor concurrency.

Philip Jenvey said...

FYI Jython is not abandoned:

JRuby has certainly had much more funding over the past few years, though

BigJason said...

Hey great post thanks. I use rails and node.js both in my personal projects and at my day job. Frankly I don't understand why people seem to think you can only like one or the other. They work well together and compliment each other very nicely. Node makes things like websockets and asynchronous network programming pleasant, but I would not want to write a full web site in it. Rails solves that problem so much better.

Just my 2 cents.

Kris Leech said...

Torquebox (Rack on JBoss) also supports web sockets.

KAMiKZ said...

Hi there I can probably understand half of what you wrote but I can't agree more that writing apps in rails or ruby is a joy , I have no cs background at all coming from group math , I stil don't know what public void stands for but ruby really cuts down on all that code noise when learning programming. And writing everything in JavaScript or simply writing anything in one language is against my personal mantra of horses for courses. Cheers !

Unknown said...

Contrary to the title, on closer reading,

the author means that while Ruby is surging, the rest of Rails, the framework itself, is dead.

Unknown said...

Contrary to the title, on closer reading,

the author means that while Ruby is surging, the rest of Rails, the framework itself, is dead.

Anonymous said...

Excellent Working Dear Friend Nice Information Share all over the world.God Bless You..
bicycle shops near london olympic village
used bicycle shops in london

daniel king said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
daniel king said...

so now it's not worth to learn rails and use rails now?

Bertrand said...

I'm a Rails developer and god knows I love the framework and the underlying technologies so I get where you're coming from and getting at, but Rails DEFINITELY doesn't make it easy to do websockets.

Cramp is nice and all, but it's not Rails now is it.

Look at any article by either Mike Perham or Ilya Grigorik from 2/3 years ago and it's suddenly obvious has a long way to go in the asynchronous/sockets department. All of which turned out to become ubiquitous in today's web programming.

So yeah, Rails is awesome is MANY ways, but it still has a way to go in some others.

Abhishek Mishra said...

Also you forgot Rubymotion - write iOS apps in Ruby. The ecosystem is growing at a good pace. It's moving towards being a very productive way of making apps :)

Blake Barnett said...

Kind hard to "forget" something that was released months after this post was made.

Christopher Rueber said...

Very well put. While I think a person could build a brand on top of any sufficiently mature system, Ruby is one of the few out there that have people constantly pushing the envelope.

Nikos Dimitrakopoulos said...

Nice writing. But still - don't take it too personal. In life there is hardly pure black and pure white. Usually it's somewhere in between them. For example I would try Node for concurrent and cutting edge stuff but as said from others I wouldn't (yet) build a real big web application on top of it.

Steve Phillips said...

Your claim: "JRuby is maturing into a high-performance Ruby implementation which taps the JVM's advanced features including the HotSpot compiler, multiple pluggable garbage collectors, and parallel multithreading which makes it suitable for multicore applications."

What the benchmarks say: JRuby running on a quad-core machine is no faster than Ruby (which can only run on 1 core)... and uses 30x the memory --

Steve Phillips said...

"The future is multicore, and if your programming language doesn't have a multicore strategy, its usefulness is vanishing."

Absolutely! And where does Ruby fit into this, you say?

"Thanks to JRuby and Rubinius, Ruby can take advantage of multicore CPUs."

Re JRuby: as pointed out in my previous comment, JRuby is no faster than Ruby, even when running on 4 cores instead of 1. Not a good sign.

Re Rubinius: on its roadmap (, the maintainers say they plan to support Ruby 1.9 with the next major release. That's right -- Rubinius doesn't even support 1.9, even though 1.9.0 was released almost 5 years ago (December 2007).

"That's OK," you may think, "they probably iterate quickly." Well, their latest release of any kind, no matter how minor, is over a year old. Their last major release is many years old.

The future isn't looking so bright for Ruby.

(My fav scripting language, Python, also has its chances at being relevant in a multicore world, but is also in trouble. I don't use Node.js and will continue using Go for my multicore needs, at least for a while. Python's JIT, PyPy, is in very active development -- much further along than Rubinius, AFAICT -- but that doesn't solve the multicore issue! PyPy is ~17x faster than CPython... but the GIL remains.)

wordalchemist said...

I was reading up on Rubinius and came across your great post. Excellent read.

Đào Tạo Vua Bếp said...

Tổng thể mẫu mã nhà phố nhìn từ bên bên cạnh, sở hữu màu trắng mau nha cap 4 dep chủ đạo khiến vượt trội ánh đèn vàng và những điểm nhấn màu đen xen kẽ tạo cảm giác đơn thuần, mộc mạc. thiết kế tuy đơn thuần nhưng mang đến dòng nhìn thanh lịch, tinh tế và ấm cúng. Phòng bếp và nhà ăn trong loại xây dựng nhà phố này được thông sở hữu nhau và vẫn đảm bảo được thể tích, quầy bar cạnh bếp tạo cảm giác thân mật ấm cúng cho bữa ăn gia đình. Phía bên này của phòng ăn nha dep là dung tích phòng khách đơn giản với lối bề ngoài mở tận dụng tuyệt đối ánh sáng ngẫu nhiên. Dung tích tuy hạn chế về khoảng trống nhưng thời trang thi công nhà phố này vẫn tạo cho ta cảm giác thông thoáng mang những điểm nhấn tinh tế. Điểm nhấn vượt trội nhất là tấm thảm độc đáo mang thời trang hiện đại và siêu hài hòa trong bối cảnh bề ngoài thi công nhà phố độc đáo này. 1 không gian sinh hoạt, tiếp khách khác của ngôi nhà với thảm gam màu trung tính làm nổi bật nội thất thi cong noi that chung cu và kết hợp dung tích. Cầu thang được đơn thuần hóa nhờ việc tiêu dùng gỗ ngẫu nhiên mang đến thể tích mộc mạc, đơn giản và tiện lợi. Hẳn đây là căn phòng dành riêng cho những cuộc gặp mặt thân mật hay các bộ phim tình cảm sướt mướt.!!!

John Alert said...

I have read your blog its very attractive and impressive. I like it your blog.

Java Training in Chennai Core Java Training in Chennai Core Java Training in Chennai

Java Online Training Java Online Training Core Java 8 Training in Chennai java 8 online training JavaEE Training in Chennai Java EE Training in Chennai

John Alert said...

ReactJS Training in CHennai ReactJS Training D3 Training in CHennai D3 Training

Yeoman Training Yeoman Training CommonJS Training in Chennai CommonJS Training Gulp TrainingGulp Training Grunt Training in Chennai Grunt Training in Chennai

John Alert said...

Online JSF Training JSF Training Institutes in Chennai Java Training Institutes Java Training Institutes Struts2 Training Institutes in Chennai Struts2 Training Institutes in Chennai

EJB Training Institutes in Chennai EJB Training Institutes in Chennai Java EE Training Institutes in Chennai Java EE Training Institutes in Chennai Java Training in CHennai

steve cook said...

nice post mate lucky

Krishna Veni said...

Good article . thanks for sharing your post

Java Training in chennai | Java Training institute in chennai |
Java Course in chennai

Roopchand Merchant said...

I am deeply attracted by your post. It is really a nice and informative one. I will recommend it to my friends.
eCommerce Service Providers

KB said...

I appreciate this work amazing post for us I like it. I must say we should have an online discussion on this. We also share some information about our business
eCommerce Inventory Management

Avinash Kanugula said...

Women's and Children's Hospital
Paediatric Hospitals In Hyderabad
Best Gynecology Hospitals in Hyderabad
Women and Child Hospitals in Hyderabad
Best Gynecologist in Hyderabad
Best Children's Hospital in Hyderabad
Child Specialist Doctor in Hyderabad

Sumit Yadav said...

Thanks for sharing this awesome post here
Dell Tech Support

Gmail Support said...

This Post has some good quality content which is a treat to read out.
Gmail customer support

Router Support said...

thanks for sharing this post with us.
Tenda Router Support Number

Gmail Support said...

Very informative post for us.
Gmail Contact Number

Aliya said...

Surveillancekart | CCTV System
Pestveda | Pest Control
Termite control
cctv installation services
best home security camera system

Anosh Alassi said...

شركة تنظيف بأبها
شركة تنظيف فلل بأبها
شركة تنظيف منازل بأبها
شركة تنظيف شقق بأبها
شركة تنظيف مجالس بأبها
شركة تنظيف موكيت بأبها
شركة تنظيف كنب بأبها
شركة تنظيف سجاد بأبها

emma said...

cctv camera dealers in delhi
cp plus cctv camera online
hikvision camera online
cctv camera installation services in delhi
cctv camera installation services in gurugram
cctv camera installation services in gurgaon

Emma said...

avriq Desktop/Laptop Repair
avriq yellow pages
avriq bbb
avriq business services
Avriq India

Escorts cart said...

Female Escorts Generations would submit to not understanding the magnificence and fantastic thing about this girl. Unprotected by the creatures that should exist in her home. She was unable to provide for them, creature or Native American.
Female Escorts,High Class Call Girls,Escorts Girls,Escorts ,Escorts near me
Female Escorts

khaled ali said...

شركة الصفرات لتنظيف الشقق بالرياض
شركة الصفرات لتنظيف الفلل بالرياض

Escorts cart said...

Female Escorts My next appointment with the Urologist was scheduled for the subsequent week. Once more I went through the routines of the waiting space, typically reading, generally simply watching the daily activities of the receptionists, however incessantly waiting. This routine would be broken every therefore often with the looks of Dr Stapleton escorting his last patient back to the receptionists and calling the next.
Female Escorts

Escorts cart said...

Female Escorts:Luckily, the barter system is also welcome, thus some families barter and exchange favors. Rather than raise cash, they will realize limousine services, rental halls, bakeries, food and drink services to participate among their poor and middle-category colleagues and friends.
Female Escorts,High Class Call Girls,Escorts Girls,Escorts ,Escorts near me
Female Escorts

Dida ELhaik said...

خدمات نقل وتخزين الاثاث
تعرف شركة شراء اثاث مستعمل جدة
ان الاثاث من اكثر الاشياء التي لها ثمن غالي ومكلف للغايةويحتاج الي عناية جيدة وشديدة لقيام بنقلة بطريقة غير مثالية وتعرضة للخدش او الكسر نحن في غني عنه فأن تلفيات الاثاث تؤدي الي التكاليف الباهظة نظرا لتكلفة الاثاث العالية كما انه يؤدي الي الحاجه الي تكلفة اضافية لشراء اثاث من جديد ،
شركة شراء اثاث مستعمل بجدة
، ونظرا لان شركة نقل اثاث بجدة من الشركات التى تعلم جيدا حجم المشكلات والاضرار التى تحدث وهي ايضا من الشركات التى على دراية كاملة بكيفية الوصول الى افضل واحسن النتائج فى عملية النقل ،كل ماعليك ان تتعاون مع شركة شراء الاثاث المستعمل بجدة والاعتماد عليها بشكل كلي في عملية نقل الاثاث من اجل الحصول علي افضل النتائج المثالية في عمليات النقل
من اهم الخدمات التي تقدمها شركة المستقبل في عملية النقل وتجعلك تضعها من
ضمن اوائل الشركات هي :
اعتماد شراء الاثاث المستعمل بجدة علي القيام بأعمال النقل علي عدة مراحل متميزة من اهما اثناء القيام بالنقل داخل المملكة او خارجها وهي مرحلة تصنيف الاثاث عن طريق المعاينة التي تتم من قبل الخبراء والفنين المتخصصين والتعرف علي اعداد القطع الموجودة من قطع خشبية او اجهزة كهربائية ا تحف او اثاث غرف وغيرهم.
كما اننا نقوم بمرحلة فك الاثاث بعد ذلك وتعتمد شركتنا في هذة المرحلة علي اقوي الاساليب والطرق المستخدمة ويقوم بذلك العملية طاقم كبير من العمالة المتربة للقيام بأعمال الفك والتركيب.
شراء اثاث مستعمل بجدة
ثم تأتي بعد ذلك مرحلة التغليف وهي من اهم المراحل التي تعمل علي الحفاظ علي اثاث منزلك وعلي كل قطعة به وتتم عملية التغليف بطريقة مميزة عن باقي الشركات.
محلات شراء الاثاث المستعمل بجدة
ويأتي بعد ذلك للمرحلة الاخيرة وهي نقل الاثاث وتركيبة ويتم اعتمادنا في عملية النقل علي اكبر الشاحنات المميزة التي تساعد علي الحفاظ علي كل قطع اثاثك اثناء عملية السير والنقل كما اننا لا نتطرق الي عمليات النقل التقليدية لخطورتها علي الاثاث وتعرضة للخدش والكسر .
تخزين الاثاث بالرياض
ارقام شراء الاثاث المستعمل بجدة
تمتلك شركة المستقبل افضل واكبر المستودعات المميزة بجدة والتي تساعد علي تحقيق اعلي مستوي من الدقة والتميز فأذا كنت في حيرة من اتمام عملية النقل والتخزين فعليك الاستعانة بشركة نقل اثاث بجدة والاتصال بنا ارقام محلات شراء الاثاث المستعمل بجدة
والتعاقد معنا للحصول علي كافة خدماتنا وعروضنا المقدمة بأفضل الاسعار المقدمة لعملائنا الكرام .

James Rose said...

Thank you to admin for sharing this with us here. This will help me out in my cv editor online and that is just the best thing for me right now. I love to read amazing things like this post here.
cartoon hd apk

shabnam praveen said...

Call girls in Kolkata
Call girls in Chandigarh
Call girls in Chandigarh
Call girls in Gurgaon
Call girls in Chandigarh
Call girls in Chandigarh

shabnam praveen said...

Call girls in Lucknow
Call girls in Guwahati
Call girls in Mumbai
Call girls in Jaipur
Call girls in Jaipur
Call girls in Jaipur
Call girls in Bangalore

Alex daina said...

This consistently expanding development is on account of conventional bank credits are not taking care of the requests of entrepreneurs. Cash Advances Chicago

Acid Eye India said...

I really want to read more your posts. They are so useful that I can use them to solve issues. I hope you will upload articles frequently. I like them very much. They are pieces of advice for me.

Acid Eye Red X2T True Wireless Earphone

Digital Marketing said...

Good to know information. Appreciate it. @ vascular doctor near me

Dida ELhaik said...


فني تركيب اثاث ايكيا بالرياضيقوم الفني بتركيب جميع الغرف الصيني الحديثة لخبرتة العالية والكبيرة في مجال تركيب الغرف الصيني فأ>ا كنت تريد شركة موثوق بها فأليك شؤكة خبراء المملكة لتركيب اثاث ايكيا بالرياض فنحن لدينا العديد من الخدمات المتنوعة التي تفيد عملائنا الكرام لاننا نسعي دائما الي التطوير وتحقيق كل ما يسعي اليه عملائنا الكرام عزيزي العميل اذا كنت في اي مكان بالرياض وتريد شركة تركيب عفش بالرياضبمنزلك او مكتبك فلديك خبراء المملكة من افضل الشركات التي تقوم بتركيب شتي انواع الاثاث الايكيا بالرياض
طريقة تركيب اثاث ايكيا
تعد شركتنا من الشركات العريقة التي لها خبرة كبيرة والتي تستخدم احدث الوسائل التكنولوجية الحديثة والمتطورة بمنتهي الدقة والاتقان بأسلوب علمي متطور وحديث في مجال تركيب الاثاث الايكيا بأرخص الاسعار التي لا تقبل المنافسة بين شركات الاخري فأسعارنا في متناول الجميع وليس لها مثيل علي الاطلاق
فني تركيب ستائر بالرياض

Luantran Huavy said...

Thanks for sharing, nice post! Post really provice useful information!

Giaonhan247 chuyên dịch vụ mua hàng trên web 1688 tiếng việt cũng như chia sẻ các web mua hàng giảm giá và tổng hợp các trang web bán hàng online uy tín uy tín và giải đáp aliexpress là gì mua hàng như thế nào.

harish sharma said...

lucky patcher

lucky patcher apk

lucky patcher download

IT Tutorials said...

Thanks for your article .its very useful for everyone. best aws training in chennai | aws course fees details

IT Tutorials said...

Thanks for your article .its very useful for everyone. best aws training in chennai | aws course fees details

اسرار ومعرفة said...

شركة كشف تسربات المياه في المملكة العربية السعودية تقدم لكم كافة الحلول لحل مشكلة تسربات المياة التي تحتاج الى فنيين ومهندسين على أعلى مستوى واجهزة خاصة تواصل معنا ولا تتردد على الرابط التالي شركة كشف تسربات مياه بالاحساء

hussain d said...

Thank you for providing these

Java Training in Bangalore
iOS Training in Bangalore

Aditya Verma said...

Very nice article I loved it. Proxy Website

Unknown said...

oil pembesar penis
cobra oil pembesar penis
vimax oil pembesar penis
kondom sambung
kondom berotot
kondom belalai gajah
ring mutiara
kondom berduri
kondom getar
kondom badak

viswanath said...

AWS Training in Bangalore - Live Online & Classroom
myTectra Amazon Web Services (AWS) certification training helps you to gain real time hands on experience on AWS. myTectra offers AWS training in Bangalore using classroom and AWS Online Training globally. AWS Training at myTectra delivered by the experienced professional who has atleast 4 years of relavent AWS experince and overall 8-15 years of IT experience. myTectra Offers AWS Training since 2013 and retained the positions of Top AWS Training Company in Bangalore and India.

IOT Training in Bangalore - Live Online & Classroom
IOT Training course observes iot as the platform for networking of different devices on the internet and their inter related communication. Reading data through the sensors and processing it with applications sitting in the cloud and thereafter passing the processed data to generate different kind of output is the motive of the complete curricula. Students are made to understand the type of input devices and communications among the devices in a wireless media.

rajesh redddy said...

Your very own commitment to getting the message throughout came to be rather powerful and have consistently enabled employees just like me to arrive at their desired goals
AngularJs Training in Bangalore
Angularjs Online Training

Akshit Arya said...

kaal sarp dosh nivaran mantra

Unknown said...

tutuapp apk


tutuapp download

Unknown said...

Nice blog thanks for sharing such useful information.
lawyers Sydney CBD

Outdoor Limited said...

Nice Blog thanks for sharing.
6.5 Creedmoor ammo

Outdoor Limited said...

Nice information, thanks for sharing this blog.
Sydney shopping

Deepika Analy said...

Great Article...Thanks for sharing the best information.It was so good to read and useful to improve my knowledge as updated one.

Android Training

MaryRYoung said...

Nice blog ! thanks for sharing.
Sydney shopping

LloydMAllen said...

Nice blog, thanks for sharing such useful information.
engagement rings Sydney

Outdoor Limited said...

Informative block thanks for sharing.
22 mag ammo

MicheleSMarsh said...

Nice blog, thanks for sharing.
22lr ammo

gaurav kaushik said...

Acid Eye
Acid Eye
Acid Eye
Acid Eye

Sri Nithya said...

Informative post, thanks for sharing.
Azure Training in Chennai | Microsoft Azure Training in Chennai | DevOps certification Chennai | DevOps Training in Chennai | AWS Training in Chennai | AWS course in Chennai

sachin kumar said...

India's only Digital News Channel with True Voice of India.
Finding #Championsofchange2018 #rahulshivkant
the universal post teams
rahul shivkant twitter
the universal post
rahul shivkant
rahul shivkant
best trending news in india

siska said...

agen domino online

alpha said...

Very Interesting and wonderful information keep sharing this post kindly check
track your order

all in one games 1 said...

See more at the link: Fildo

Unknown said...

myTectra a global learning solutions company helps transform people and organization to gain real, lasting benefits.Join Today.Ready to Unlock your Learning Potential ! Read More....

Hanna Willam said...

I am very happy to read this. Very interesting! Thanks you . You have posted a trust worthy blog keep sharing
Hyundai Xcent Double Din Player
Tata Nexon Double Din Player
Hyundai Verna
Hypersonic OEM Double Din Player
J3l USB Double Din Player
Double Din DVD Player
car accessories
Hyundai Creta OEM Double Din Player
Hyundai i20 OEM Double Din Player
Hyundai Grand i10 OEM Double Din Player

Ananya Krishnan said...

Good job in presenting the correct content with the clear explanation. The content looks real with valid information. Good Work

DevOps is currently a popular model currently organizations all over the world moving towards to it. Your post gave a clear idea about knowing the DevOps model and its importance.

Good to learn about DevOps at this time.

devops training in chennai | devops training in chennai with placement | devops training in chennai omr | devops training in velachery | devops training in chennai tambaram | devops institutes in chennai | devops certification in chennai

toko erogan said...

Obat Erogan Asli
Obat Pembesar Penis Erogan Asli
Erogan Asli
Testimoni Erogan Asli
Obat Erogan Asli
Obat Erogan Usa Asli
Ciri Ciri Erogan Asli
Ciri Ciri Obat Erogan Palsu
Ciri Ciri Obat Erogan Asli Dan Palsu
Obat Penirum Asli
Obat Pembesar Penis Penirum Asli
Penirum Asli
Testimoni Penirum Asli
Obat Penirum Asli Usa
Ciri Ciri Penirum Asli
Ciri Ciri Penirum Palsu
Ciri Ciri Penirum Asli Dan Palsu
Obat Penirum Asli
Obat Pembesar Penis Penirum Asli
Penirum Asli
Testimoni Penirum Asli
Obat Penirum Asli Usa
Ciri Ciri Penirum Asli
Ciri Ciri Penirum Palsu
Ciri Ciri Penirum Asli Dan Palsu
Jual Obat Kuat Viagra Usa Di Jakarta
Jual Viagra Di Jakarta
Jual Vimax Asli Di Jakarta
Agen Vimax Canada Di Jakarta
Jual Hammer Ofthor Asli
Hammer Of Thor Di Jakarta

Saro said...

This is most informative and also this post most user friendly and super navigation to all posts... Thank you so much for giving this information to me.. 

rpa online training |
rpa course in bangalore |
rpa training in bangalore |
rpa training institute in bangalore

Amar G said...

Selenium is one of the most popular automated testing tool used to automate various types of applications. Selenium is a package of several testing tools designed in a way for to support and encourage automation testing of functional aspects of web-based applications and a wide range of browsers and platforms and for the same reason, it is referred to as a Suite.

Selenium Interview Questions and Answers
Javascript Interview Questions
Human Resource (HR) Interview Questions

gowsalya said...

It is amazing and wonderful to visit your site.Thanks for sharing this information,this is useful to me...
excel advanced excel training in bangalore | Devops Training in Chennai

Sample Data said...


Mouni yoga said...

This is most informative and also this post most user friendly and super navigation to all posts... Thank you so much for giving this information to me.. 
python course in pune
python course in chennai
python course in Bangalore

suresh H said...

I simply want to tell you that I am just beginner to blogs and absolutely enjoyed you’re the website. More than likely I’m planning to bookmark your blog. You really come with awesome stories.

RPA Training in Chennai

DevOps Training

Python Training in Chennai

simbu said...

Nice information, valuable and excellent design, as share good stuff with good ideas and concepts, lots of great information and inspiration, both of which I need, thanks to offer such a helpful information here.
Oracle training in Chennai

Java training in Chennai | Java training in Annanagar

Java training in Chennai | Java training institute in Chennai | Java course in Chennai

Java training in Chennai | Java training institute in Chennai | Java course in Chennai

shalinipriya said...

Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't wait to read lots of your posts
Data Science training in rajaji nagar | Data Science Training in Bangalore
Data Science with Python training in chennai
Data Science training in electronic city
Data Science training in USA
Data science training in pune

amsa leka said...

Thanks for your great and helpful presentation I like your good service.I always appreciate your post. That is very interesting I love reading and I am always searching for informative information like this.
Well written article. Thank You Sharing with Us android quiz questions and answers | android code best practices | android development for beginners | future of android development 2018 | android device manager location history

Lucille Parham said...

The information and facts talked about within the post are a few of the most effective obtainable. Visit us:

vimal kumar said...

I am really happy with your blog because your article is very unique and powerful for new reader.
Click here:
selenium training in chennai | selenium course in chennai
selenium training in bangalore | selenium course in bangalore
selenium training in Pune | selenium course in pune | selenium class in pune
selenium training in Pune | selenium course in pune | selenium class in pune
selenium online training | selenium training online | online training on selenium

pavithra dass said...

Thank you for taking the time and sharing this information with us. It was indeed very helpful and insightful while being straight forward and to the point.
RPA Training in Chennai
Robotics Process Automation Training in Chennai
RPA courses in Chennai
Robotic Process Automation Training
RPA course
Robotic Process Automation Certification

Shadeep shree said...

The blog which you have shared is more informative. Thanks for your information.
JAVA Training Center in Coimbatore
JAVA Training
JAVA Certification Course
JAVA Certification Training
JAVA Training Courses

swetha singh said...

This information is impressive; I am inspired with your post. Keep posting like this, This is very useful.Thank you so much. Waiting for more blogs like this.
Airport management courses in chennai
airline management courses in chennai
aircraft maintenance course in chennai
diploma in airport management in chennai

sattaking2018 said...

satta king desawar

satta king online

satta king chart

satta king gali

satta king in

satta king 2018

satta king2018

Dwarakesh babu said...

Greetings. I know this is somewhat off-topic, but I was wondering if you knew where I could get a captcha plugin for my comment form? I’m using the same blog platform like yours, and I’m having difficulty finding one? Thanks a lot.
AWS Training in Pune | Best Amazon Web Services Training in Pune

Amazon Web Services Training in OMR , Chennai | Best AWS Training in OMR,Chennai

AWS Training in Chennai |Best Amazon Web Services Training in Chennai

sweety ganga said...

I love the blog. Great post. It is very true, people must learn how to learn before they can learn. lol i know it sounds funny but its very true. . .
angularjs Training in bangalore

angularjs Training in bangalore

angularjs Training in chennai

automation anywhere online Training

angularjs interview questions and answers

Rithi Rawat said...

Thankyou for providing the information, I am looking forward for more number of updates from you thank you machine learning training center in chennai

artificial intelligence and machine learning course in chennai

machine learning classroom training in chennai

lekha mathan said...

Very interesting post! Thanks for sharing your experience suggestions.
Aviation Academy in Chennai
Aviation Courses in Chennai
best aviation academy in chennai
aviation institute in chennai

jenifer irene said...

Thanks for providing wonderful information with us. Thank you so much.
Air hostess training in Chennai
Air Hostess Training Institute in chennai
air hostess course fees structure in chennai
air hostess training academy in chennai

kavinilavu G said...

Really Great..Thanks for sharing..keep update php training in chennai
php training in velachery chennai
php course fees in chennai
best php training institute in chennai

Nadeem Malik said...

hi, nice information is given in this blog. Thanks for sharing this type of information, it is so useful for me. nice work keep it up. digital marketing company in delhi

Unknown said...

Thanks for sharing this unique information with us.
- Learn Digital Academy

Nadeem Malik said...

visa immigration service in delhi

sachin.ogeninfo said...

cattle feed bags manufacturer

sachin.ogeninfo said...

Cattle Feed Bags Manufacturer
Rice Packaging Bags Manufacturers
dry fruit Pouches supplier

sachin.ogeninfo said...

Punjabi song lyrics

fooooiol said...

new year wallpapers 10

Infocampus said...

Thanks for sharing the most informative content.
selenium training in Bangalore
selenium courses in Bangalore
selenium training in Marathahalli
selenium training institute in bangalore

best web development training in Bangalore
web development course in bangalore
best web development training in Bangalore
web development training in Marathahalli


mounika said...

Nice post..

robotics courses in BTM

robotic process automation training in BTM

blue prism training in BTM

rpa training in BTM

automation anywhere training in BTM

Akash Thakur said...

Epoxy Grout manufacturer in delhi

Vikash Kumar said...

Laminated Doors manufacturer in hubli

Amase LED Lighting said...

led lawn lights in delhi
Thanks for giving great kind of information. So useful and practical for me. Thanks for your excellent blog, nice work keep it up thanks for sharing the knowledge.

ram ramky said...

Thank you for the blog. It was a really exhilarating for me.

selenium training in velachery
Selenium Training in Chennai
Big Data Training in Chennai
web designing training in chennai
german language classes
german teaching institutes in chennai

Splendid Interiors said...

I can only express a word of thanks! Nothing else. Because your topic is nice, you can add knowledge. Thank you very much for sharing this information.
Find the Best Interior Designs for Bedroom in Vijayawada

Nadeem Malik said...

hello sir,
thanks for giving that type of information.
digital marketing company in delhi
Hp Plotter Dealer in Delhi
Best Ways to Optimize Your Website for Lead Generation

lather said...

Goyal packers and movers in Panchkula is highly known for their professional and genuine packing and moving services. We are top leading and certified relocation services providers in Chandigarh deals all over India. To get more information, call us.

Packers and movers in Chandigarh
Packers and movers in Panchkula
Packers and movers in Mohali
Packers and movers in Zirakpur
Packers and movers in Patiala
Packers and movers in Ambala
Packers and movers in Ambala cantt
Packers and movers in Pathankot
Packers and movers in Jalandhar
Packers and movers in Ludhiana


If you live in Delhi and looking for a good and reliable vashikaran specialist in Delhi to solve all your life problems, then you are at right place. 
love marriage specialist in delhi

vashikaran specialist in delhi

love vashikaran specialist molvi ji

get love back by vashikaran

black magic specialist in Delhi

husband wife problem solution

click track India said...

Thinking of growing as best packers and movers in Mohali? Just click on click track india, and you are ready for the skyrocket sales.

Packers and movers in Chandigarh

Packers and movers in Mohali

Packers and movers in Noida

Packers and movers in Gurgaon

Packers and movers in Delhi NCR

Packers and movers in Bangalore

Praylin S said...

Awesome post! Thanks for sharing this great post. I'm gathering a lot of information from here. Keep us updated with more such posts.
Oracle Training in Chennai | Oracle Training institute in chennai | Oracle course in Chennai | Oracle Training | Oracle Certification in Chennai | Best oracle training institute in Chennai | Best oracle training in Chennai | Oracle training center in Chennai | Oracle institute in Chennai

Riya Raj said...

Blog is really great!!! Thanks for the sharing…
Angularjs Training in Chennai
Angularjs Training in Bangalore
Angularjs course in Chennai
Angularjs Training Institute in Bangalore

sathyaramesh said...

Superb. I really enjoyed very much with this article here. Really it is an amazing article I had ever read. I hope it will help a lot for all. Thank you so much for this amazing posts and please keep update like this excellent article.thank you for sharing such a great blog with us. expecting for your.
Blue prism training in bangalore
Blue prism training bangalore
Blue prism classes in bangalore
Blue Prism Training Centers in Bangalore
Blue Prism Institute in Bangalore

toko erogan said...

Vitamale Asli

Ciri Ciri Vitamale Asli

Obat Erogan Asli

Obat Pembesar Penis Erogan Asli

Erogan Asli

Testimoni Erogan Asli

Obat Erogan Asli


Obat Erogan Usa Asli

Ciri Ciri Erogan Asli

Ciri Ciri Obat Erogan Palsu

Ciri Ciri Obat Erogan Asli Dan Palsu

Obat Penirum Asli

Obat Pembesar Penis Penirum Asli

Penirum Asli

Testimoni Penirum Asli

Obat Penirum Asli Usa

Ciri Ciri Penirum Asli

Ciri Ciri Penirum Palsu

Ciri Ciri Penirum Asli Dan Palsu

Obat Penirum Asli

Obat Pembesar Penis Penirum Asli

Penirum Asli

Testimoni Penirum Asli

Obat Penirum Asli Usa

Ciri Ciri Penirum Asli

Ciri Ciri Penirum Palsu

Ciri Ciri Penirum Asli Dan Palsu

Jual Obat Kuat Viagra Usa Di Jakarta

Jual Viagra Di Jakarta

Jual Vimax Asli Di Jakarta

Agen Vimax Canada Di Jakarta

Jual Hammer Ofthor Asli

Hammer Of Thor Di Jakarta



Unknown said...

tutuapp download
tutuapp Android

sai said...

This is a good post. This post give truly quality information. I’m definitely going to look into it. Really very useful tips are provided here. thank you so much. Keep up the good works.
python Training in Bangalore | Python Training institute in Bangalore

Data Science training in Chennai | Data Science Training Institute in Chennai

cynthia williams said...

Useful content, I have bookmarked this page for my future reference. Keep sharing more like this.
Learn R programming
R Training in Chennai
R Training near me
R Programming Training in Chennai
Data Analytics Training
R Training in Velachery

Best Sexologist in India said...

Dr. Vinod Raina is one of the well-known sex specialist doctors in Delhi, NCR, and India.
Top Sexologist Online Dr Vinod

nanadhini chandran said...

Your blog is interesting for have developed your blog informations with such a wonderful ideas and which is very much

useful for the readers.i enjoyed your post and i need some more articles also please update soon.
Cloud Computing Courses
Cloud computing Courses in Velachery
Cloud Computing Training in Adyar
Hadoop Training in Chennai
Selenium Training in Chennai
JAVA Training in Chennai

Aruna Ram said...

Your content is very effectively! Thanks to your depth explanation and good job. Keep update on some more details.
PHP Training in Bangalore
PHP Course in Bangalore
PHP Training in Anna Nagar
PHP Course in Anna Nagar
PHP Training in Tnagar
PHP Course in Tnagar
PHP Training in Omr
PHP Course in Omr

Akash Thakur said...

Thanks for giving great kind of information. So useful and practical for me. Thanks for your excellent blog, nice work keep it up thanks for sharing the knowledge.
interior designer company in noida

Splendid Interiors said...

Ah,so beautiful and wonderful post!An opportunity to read a fantastic and imaginary blogs.It gives me lots of pleasure and interest.Thanks for sharing.
Find the Best Interior Design for Home in Visakhapatnam

Vikash Kumar said...

nice work keep it up thanks for sharing the knowledge.Thanks for sharing this type of information, it is so useful.
cement bonder manufacturer in delhi

Amase LED Lighting said...

Indoor LED Wall Lights in delhi
Thanks for giving great kind of information. So useful and practical for me. Thanks for your excellent blog, nice work keep it up thanks for sharing the knowledge.

jeewangarg said...

I have been a keen follower of your website.
recently I came across this topic and after reading the whole article I am amazed that how well you have written it.
Amazing writing skills shown.
You have done a good research on this topic.
Great Work.

- Jeewan Garg - Website Designing Company

Anbarasan14 said...

Thanks to the admin of this blog for sharing these kinds of useful information; Have been waiting for more updates.

Spoken English Classes in Anna Nagar
Spoken English Classes in Chennai Anna Nagar
Spoken English Classes in T-Nagar
Spoken English Classes in Coimbatore
Spoken English Class in Coimbatore
IELTS Coaching in Tambaram
IELTS Coaching Centre in Tambaram

مروة محمد said...

شركة تسليك مجاري بالخبر

Sadhana Rathore said...

Great blog with lots of information, continue sharing more like this.
AngularJS Training in Chennai
AngularJS course in Chennai
AngularJS Training Institute in Chennai
Angular 6 Training in Chennai
ReactJS Training in Chennai

Lyrics said... is a huge collection of song lyrics , album information and featured video clips for a seemingly endless array of artists.

watt said...

You need to watch this in cinema. Acting, action and youjizz was GOLD! Ending was great. Soundwave has an actual G1 voice.

Raja said...

final grade calculator
flipkart customer care

Infocampus Logics Pvt Ltd said...

Nice post.
Python Training in Bangalore
Best Institute For Python Training in Marathahalli
Best Python Training Institutes in Bangalore
Python Training Center in Bangalore BTM
class in Bangalore marathahalli
python courses in Bangalore

jefrin adams said...

Very good to read this post
best azure certification training in chennai

minakshi said...

Are you trying to move in or out of Jind? or near rohtak Find the most famous, reputed and the very best of all Packers and Movers by simply calling or talking to Airavat Movers and Packers

Packers And Movers in Jind

Packers And Movers in Rohtak

Movers And Packers in Rohtak

S Happy said...

Nice post. It is really interesting. Thanks for sharing.
Hotels in Tuticorin, Hotels in Thoothukudi, Best Hotel in Tuticorin

Sachin Sinhmar said...

we have provide the best ppc service in Gurgaon.
ppc company in gurgaon
website designing company in Gurgaon