Monday, December 8, 2008

Fair Use on YouTube

...does not exist. In the wake of enormous lawsuits from old media companies, YouTube has been cracking down on copyright violations with a vengeance, deploying sophisticated audio and video fingerprinting systems to detect and automatically remove infringing content. A video I created and uploaded was removed by this system, and I can't help but feel angry my fair use rationale was completely ignored. Internet video brings with it the dream of blowing away many of the practical limitations on the free expression of ideas in the video medium. Sadly, in bowing to old media interests, YouTube has turned the power of a digital video distribution system against content producers, deploying fully automated mechanisms for enforcing old media copyrights while completely ignoring fair use rationale.

Let's begin with a little bit of background on my video...

I posted a "remix" of the video of Rihanna's song "Umbrella." My remix omitted all verses except the first, and looped the chorus... over and over and over again. What was that chorus, you ask?
You can stand under my umber-ella
You can stand under my umber-ella ella ella eh eh eh
Under my um-buh-rella ella ella eh eh eh
Under my um-buh-rella ella ella eh eh eh
Under my um-buh-rella ella ella eh eh eh eh eh eh
The comments of my video made note that when I first heard the song, it was as if I was channeling Christopher Walken, except rather than the song needing more cowbell, it needed more "ella ella ella eh eh eh". Of course, this wasn't quite the truth, I actually stole the idea from a video which did similar chorus looping on a Nirvana video with a similarly repetitive chorus. My reaction was both Kurt and grunge are dead, so why not pick on a song that's more deserving, say one by a present-day pop idol.

But more than ripping off an idea from another YouTube video, the heart of me making this video lay in, well, yet another YouTube video. Some years earlier I had seen a music video by British rapper Scroobius Pip, for the song "Thou Shalt Always Kill." It's loaded with all sorts of observations about music itself, perhaps culminating in a long rant in which the artist names a long list of sacred cow bands like the Beatles, Led Zeppelin, The Beach Boys, and... Nirvana, adding after saying each one's name that they're "just a band." If you're a fan of, well, music, chances are at least one of your favorites is somewhere in that list, if not several. Scroobius Pip just wants you to keep it in perspective and not put recording artists on pedistals no matter how great they are or were. Such a tirade is repetitive in nature, however the totality of the expression is anything but. That's the sort of repition I can enjoy. Rihanna's is not.

All that said, despite the awesomeness of the "Your sacred cow is just a band" chorus, it does not stick out in my mind. My favorite part in the video is when Scroobius Pip sticks his face on a copy machine, and begins singing:
Thou shalt not make repetitive generic music!
Thou shalt not make repetitive generic music!
Thou shalt not make repetitive generic music!
Thou shalt not make repetitive generic music!
The first time I heard Umbrella was after having heard this chorus, and it immediately stuck out in my mind as one of the foremost examples of repetitive, generic music. After seeing the Nirvana song with a looped chorus (even though I kind of like Sliver) I decided I had to do that to Umbrella.

So I did. I edited the video, splicing up the various times the chorus is repeated in various parts of the video into small chunks, and producing random smatterings of those chunks. The result is two minutes of random clips from the video backed by a nonstop "ELLA ELLA ELLA EH EH EH" sound track.

I posted the resulting video to the social news site Reddit, and while it wasn't received very well I was happy to see that someone responded to my post with "Thou shall not make repetitive generic music Thou shall not make repetitive generic music Thou shall not make repetitive generic music." Upon seeing this I felt that what I had created was in some way an artform which had managed to ineffably communicate the sentiments of its inspiration.

The video was up for about two months, receiving a meager 2,000 views. I would occasionally go back to it and watch it again, wondering how much it would offend Rihanna if she ever saw it, not that I have anything personal against Rihanna. But I would like to see how an artist who records such repetitive music would react when such repetition is made painfully clear.

However, today I received the following e-mail from YouTube. It seems their audio fingerprinting system had analyzed the song's chorus looped over and over umpteen times and been able to conclusively identify it. YouTube sent me the following message:
A copyright owner has claimed it owns some or all of the audio content in your video Rihanna - Umbrella (Extended ELLA ELLA EH EH Mix). The audio content identified in your video is Umbrella by Rihanna. We regret to inform you that your video has been blocked from playback due to a music rights issue.
At the bottom of the e-mail they gave me the option to visit the Copyright Notice page of my account if I felt there had been a mistake. I hope from reading my sentiments earlier in this post you've gathered I feel I have a pretty good fair use rationale. I felt my version was an obvious parody which painfully hits the listener over the head with how highly repetitive the song is.

So I hopped onto YouTube's Copyright Notice page, and entered a dispute against the automated copyright claim. YouTube had conveniently provided me an option on the form to select: "This video uses copyrighted material in a manner that does not require approval of the copyright holder. It is a fair use under copyright law." For my fair use defense, I entered the following:
I claim fair use as this video is a parody of the original work. It has been remixed/altered to highlight, exaggerate, and ridicule the highly repetitive nature of the source material.
Of course there was far more to it than that, but I thought this would be good enough to warrant some human attention. I noted an ominous warning: if my fair use rationale were not accepted, my video would be permanently deleted. Noting this, I clicked submit.

No sooner than clicking the button was I notifed that my fair use argument had been rejected and my video deleted:
In response to your dispute of a content identification match, UMG has reviewed your video Rihanna - Umbrella (Extended ELLA ELLA EH EH Mix) and confirmed their claim to some or all of its audio content. As a result, your video is no longer available.
What the hell? My fair use claim was forwarded to a record label's automatic fair use claim-rejecting robot, and automatically rejected. My thoughts as a video producer were completely ignored and my content was automatically removed from the system. At no point in this process did any human ever review any part of my defense. Instead completely automated systems mechanically crushed any semblance of fair use rights I thought I had.

And what's the point? The automated systems have clobbered my fair use rights, but I'm free to retaliate by just uploading the video again. And so I have:

...except this time I'm taking a stand and actively asserting my fair use rights. Perhaps if I draw enough attention to this video I can actually get in touch with a human at YouTube who is able to do something more than automatically reject my fair use rationale.


Amir Amirty said...

جویدن غذا و فواید بیشتر و طولانی جویدن غذا بر سلامتی
لقاح و نکاتی در مورد لقاح و بارداری که خانم ها باید بدانند
زگیل و روش های موثر برای از بین بردن آن روی صورت و دست و پا

shina said...

Surveillancekart | CCTV System
cctv installation services
best home security camera system
cctv camera for home
Pestveda | Pest Control
Termite control

rajesh khanna said...

cctv camera dealers in delhi
cp plus cctv camera online
hikvision camera online
cctv camera installation services in delhi
cctv camera installation services in gurugram
cctv camera installation services in gurgaon
cctv camera installation services in noida
cctv camera security systems
cctv installation services
security systems for home

Amir Amirty said...


robin said...

avriq Desktop/Laptop Repair
avriq yellow pages
avriq business services
avriq bbb
avriq India

mariablack said...

Pc Optimization
Windows Installation
Data Recovery

shabnam praveen said...

Call girls in Kolkata
Call girls in Chandigarh
Call girls in Chandigarh
Call girls in Gurgaon
Call girls in Chandigarh
Call girls in Chandigarh

shabnam praveen said...

Call girls in Lucknow
Call girls in Guwahati
Call girls in Mumbai
Call girls in Jaipur
Call girls in Jaipur
Call girls in Jaipur
Call girls in Bangalore

siska said...

Main Togel Online

Unknown said...

Thanks a lot. This is very detailed and informational post. Thanks a lotSI kaise bane

Ananya Krishnan said...

Good job in presenting the correct content with the clear explanation. The content looks real with valid information. Good Work

DevOps is currently a popular model currently organizations all over the world moving towards to it. Your post gave a clear idea about knowing the DevOps model and its importance.

Good to learn about DevOps at this time.

devops training in chennai | devops training in chennai with placement | devops training in chennai omr | devops training in velachery | devops training in chennai tambaram | devops institutes in chennai | devops certification in chennai

กวิน ฮา said...

slot online
casino online

cheipzs 64 said...

ฟินกันให้สุด ๆ กับโปรโมชั่นโบนัสเงินฝากรายวัน E-SPORTS 10% จ่ายโบนัสสูงสุดถึง 2,500 บาท ฝากทุกวัน รวยทุกวันสล็อตออนไลน์ บาคาร่า

สมัครเลย >>> satu88 <<< said...


Ghost Company said...

There were a lot of rumblings out there in the video game industry that something major was coming to the Android world, but most people would never have assumed that it was a full Android version of what many consider to be one of the best video games in human history .download gta v apk free for android

nongdeerza111 zazaza said...


nongdeerza111 zazaza said...

โปรโมชั่น Goldenslot สมัครสมาชิกใหม่
โปรโมชั่น Goldenslotสมัครสมาชิกใหม่ พร้อมโปรโมชั่นเติมเงิน แบบครบวงจร รับสูงสุด 1,000 บาท
สมัครสมาชิกคลิก>>> Golden slot

nongdeerza111 zazaza said...

golden slotให้บริการ สล็อตออนไลน์ ระดับโลก
golden slot ผู้ให้บริการ สล็อตออนไลน์ ระดับโลก
โปรโมชั่นสำหรับ goldenslot เท่านั้น เติมมาเท่าไหร่ รับไปเลย โบนัส พิเศษ 15% ไม่ลิมิต ยอดโบนัสสูงสุด ยิ่งเติม โกเด้นสล๊อต มากยิ่งได้มาก
สมัครสมาชิกที่นี่ >>> สล็อตออนไลน์
สมัครสมาชิกที่นี่ >>> สล็อตออนไลน์
สมัครสมาชิกที่นี่ >>> สล็อตออนไลน์

casinoxo said...

ที่สุด ของเว็บไซต์ให้บริการสล็อตได้เงินจริงที่ยอดที่สุดในไทย รับประกันการมอบเงินจริง ให้แน่ไม่มีทางหลอก แค่เข้ามาเล่นสล็อตได้เงินจริงที่เว็บไซต์เรา คุณก็จะได้เจอกับโลกใหม่ที่น่าตื่นตาตื่นใจ โลกที่จะมอบรางวัลมากมายมหาศาลให้ท่านได้อย่างไม่มีจำกัด รับรองให้แน่จ่ายจริง แค่สล็อตได้เงินจริงที่เว็บไซต์เราเท่านั้น >>> สล็อตได้เงินจริง

cheipzs 64 said...

golden slot ผู้ให้บริการ สล็อตออนไลน์ ระดับโลก
โปรโมชั่นสำหรับ goldenslot เท่านั้น เติมมาเท่าไหร่ รับไปเลย โบนัส พิเศษ 15% ไม่ลิมิต ยอดโบนัสสูงสุด ยิ่งเติม โกเด้นสล๊อต มากยิ่งได้มาก
สมัครสมาชิกที่นี่ >>> สล็อตออนไลน์
สมัครสมาชิกที่นี่ >>> สล็อตออนไลน์
สมัครสมาชิกที่นี่ >>> สล็อตออนไลน์

กวิน ฮา said...

คลิก>>> gclub
คลิก>>> จีคลับ
คลิก>>> gclub casino
คลิก>>> คาสิโนออนไลน์
คลิก>>> สล็อตออนไลน์

GD SLOT K said...

One2bet เว็ปมาแรง แจกกระจาย
golden slot

Pankaj Singh said...

Nice blog gets one of the best website designing service by the best website designing company in delhi, India.
Website Designing Company

Neha Sharma said...

Rice Bags Manufacturers
Pouch Manufacturers
wall putty bag manufacturers
Lyrics with music

Neha Sharma said...

we have provide the best ppc service.
ppc company in gurgaon
website designing company in Gurgaon
PPC company in Noida
seo company in gurgaon
PPC company in Mumbai
PPC company in Chandigarh

Neha Sharma said...

we have provide the best fridge repair service.
fridge repair in faridabad
Videocon Fridge Repair in Faridabad
Whirlpool Fridge Repair in Faridabad
Hitachi Fridge Repair In Faridabad
Washing Machine Repair in Noida
godrej washing machine repair in noida
whirlpool Washing Machine Repair in Noida
IFB washing Machine Repair in Noida
LG Washing Machine Repair in Noida

Neha Sharma said...

Bali Honeymoon Packages From Delhi
Bali Honeymoon Packages From Chennai
Hong Kong Packages From Delhi
Europe Packages from Delhi
Bali Honeymoon Packages From Bangalore
Bali Honeymoon Packages From Mumbai
Maldives Honeymoon Packages From Bangalore
travel company in Delhi

Neha Sharma said...

gmp certification in delhi
halal certification in delhi
ce certification in delhi
iso 13485 certification in delhi
website designing services
seo serivces in delhi

Mutual Fundwala said...

Nice blog, get the best Mutual Fund Advise and Investment Schemes by Mutualfundwala.
Mutual Fund Companies

90minup said...

เทียบพยัญชนะสระอังกฤษไทย แอพ
ด่าน มีด่านบอกด้วย