Monday, March 5, 2012

Why critics of Rails have it all wrong (and Ruby's bright multicore future)

Edit: Contrary to what I said here, José Valim is not stepping down from Rails core, he is merely on sabbatical. My bad.

Lately I've been getting the feeling the Ruby community has gotten a bit emo. The enthusiasm surrounding how easy Ruby makes it to write clean, concise, well-tested web applications quickly is fading. Rails has become merely a day job for many. Whatever hype surrounded Rails at its inception has died down into people who are just getting work done.

Meanwhile, Node.js is the new hotness, and many in the Node community have sought to build Node up by bringing Ruby and Rails down. I know that once upon a time Ruby enthusiasts were doing this sort of thing to Java. However, the tables have turned, and where Ruby used to be the mudslinging hype-monkey, it's now become the whipping boy and Node.js the new provocateur.

The sad thing is many of these people are former or current Rubyists who have taken a liking to Node and build it up by spreading blatant untruths about Ruby. I won't go as far as to call them liars, but at the very least, they are extremely misinformed, ignorant of the state of the Ruby ecosystem, and pushing their own agendas.

Jeremy Ashkenas, the creator of CoffeeScript, recently trashed Rails 3 and claimed "Node.js won":


The idea that Rails 3 was a major step backward was recently reiterated by both Giles Bowkett and Matt Aimonetti. Both of them painted building ActionController::Metal applications as some sort of byzantine, impossible task which can only be accomplished by a Rails core member. Are people actually building lightweight Rails applications using the newfound modularity of Rails 3?


Jose Valim, (now former) Rails core member, published a small, simple gist illustrating how to build barebones apps on ActionController::Metal (one of the most forked gists I've ever seen) which is further documented in his book Crafting Rails Applications. In just 50 lines of code you can strip Rails down to its core, making it ideal for use in modern client-heavy HTML5 applications. The funny thing about this gist is that while the idea of a 50 line Rails app seems pretty impressive, the basis of that gist is what Rails 3 puts into your config/boot.rb, environment.rb, and application.rb, just combined into a single file. Did I just blow your mind? Sadly, all the (in my opinion completely undeserved) bad press seems to have made Jose emo as well, and he has stepped down from Rails to pursue his Elixir language.

ActionController::Metal-based applications (along with apps written in Clojure) were the basis of our backend at Strobe, where we sought to ease the pains of people building modern client-heavy HTML5/JS applications with frameworks including SproutCore/Ember, Backbone, and Spine. ActionController::Metal provided a great, fully-featured, mature, and modular platform for us to build applications on top of, and Strobe's ActionController::Metal stack for client-heavy HTML5/JS applications is available on Github. The apps we built with the Strobe ActionController::Metal stack talked only JSON and our frontend was an HTML5/JS application written with SproutCore.

Before Strobe, I worked at a company building rich HTML/JS applications for digital television. Our backend was written in Rails. Our frontends were Flash and HTML/JS applications, the latter of which were single-page client-heavy HTML/JS apps that were packaged in .zip files and installed onto digital televisions and set top boxes, a sort of weird hybrid of web technologies and installable applications. Our Rails application didn't have any views, but provided only a JSON API for the HTML/JS frontend to consume.

Rails was great for this, because it provided the sort of high level abstractions we needed in order to be productive, ensure our application was well-tested, and above all else provided the necessary foundation for clean, maintainable code. I was doing this in 2008, and even then this was already considered old hat in the Rails community. In case you're not paying attention, that's one year before Node even existed.

Modern HTML5/JS apps depend on beautiful, consistent RESTful JSON APIs. This is a great way to develop rich interactive applications, because it separates the concerns of what the backend business logic is doing from the view layer entirely. Separate teams, each specialized in their role, can develop the frontend and backend independently, the frontend people concerned with creating a great user experience, and the backend people concerned with building a great API the frontend application can consume.

Rails is great for JSON APIs.

And yet this meme persists, that somehow Rails is actually bad at JSON APIs. Those who propagate this meme insist that Rails has lost its edge, and that only Node understands the needs of these sorts of modern client-heavy web applications. Giles recently attempted to argue this position:


Giles recently blogged about this issue at length. Let's look at what he has to say about ActionController::Metal and the new level of modularity and clean design that Rails 3 brings to the table:


So Jose wrote a great book about the incredible power of Rails 3's new modular APIs... but... but... but what?

WARD CUNNINGHAM BITCHES. TWEETS > BOOKS. NODE WINS. QED.

Hurrrrrrrr? Ward Cunningham is a cool guy and his concept of a Wiki was a transformative technology for the web, but what the fuck does that have to do with Rails 3's new modular APIs or Jose's book? I think that's what people in logical debate circles call a "non-sequitur".

Perhaps there's still a cogent argument to be had here. Let's dig deeper:


Okay, so the problem is there's not a damn simple way to do websockets. OH WAIT, THERE IS:


Cramp is an awesome, easy-to-use websockets/server-sent events framework (with socket.io support) which runs on Rainbows or Thin, and Thin is a great web server. According to my benchmarks it's approximately the same speed as Node's web server:

Web Server            Throughput  Latency
----------            ----------  -------
Thin    (1.2.11)      8747 reqs/s (7.3 ms/req)
Node.js (0.6.5)       9023 reqs/s (7.1 ms/req)
Yes folks, Node isn't significantly faster than Ruby at web server performance. They're about the same.

Giles also bemoans bundler, because typing "bundle exec" represents ceremony, and using any of the myriad solutions to avoid typing "bundle exec", such as bundler binstubs or rvm gemsets, represents configuration which violates the Rails mantra of "convention over configuration", and how npm is that much easier. I'm sure we would all love to not have to add a one line .rvmrc file to each project to avoid typing "bundle exec", but uhh Giles, bro, mountain out of a molehill much?

Meanwhile, let's check out how convention over configuration is going in the JavaScript world:


But enough about Giles... what kinds of awesome, modern HTML5 applications are people using Rails to build?

I think one of the best examples of this sort of application is Travis CI. Travis is an open source distributed build system with an Ember-based frontend and a Rails backend. Travis's interface shows, in real time, the state of all builds across the entire (distributed) system, allows you to interactively explore the history, see the distributed build matrix completing jobs in realtime, and even have it stream the console output of builds in progress directly to your browser as they complete. It's an amazing, modern client-heavy HTML5/JS application, and it's built on Rails.

Who else is using Ruby/Rails for their frontend? Oh, just Twitter, LivingSocial, Groupon, Heroku, EngineYard, Github, Square, Zendesk, Shopify, Yammer, Braintree, Boundary, Stripe, Parse, Simple, and of course let's not forget 37signals. Rails is the technology underlying the frontend web stack of many huge businesses. Many of these companies have client-heavy HTML5/JS applications which consume a JSON API coming out of Rails. Many of them have APIs that are routinely cited as archetypical RESTful JSON APIs. Many of them have top notch engineering teams that choose the best tools for the job and use many languages for many different tasks. Many of them were founded "post-Node" and had the opportunity to choose Node as their frontend web technology, and while they may use Node in some capacity, their main consumer-facing sites are written with Rails.

Node is three years old now. Where are the Node.js success stories? Who's built a brand on top of Node?  Nodejitsu? Hubot? Is Node anything more than a pyramid scheme or a platform for Campfire bots? Where Rails selling points eschewed performance and instead focused on clear code, rapid development, extensive testing, and quick time-to-market, Node's selling points seem to universally revolve around its insanely fast, destroy the internet fast performance (benchmarks not provided). Meanwhile code quality is de-emphasized and large Node programs degrade into incomprehensible, byzantine structures of callbacks and flow-control libraries, instead of being written in sequential code, you know, the code you can read:

 

What about Ruby in general? What advancements in the Ruby ecosystem are worth getting excited about?

JRuby is maturing into a high-performance Ruby implementation which taps the JVM's advanced features including the HotSpot compiler, multiple pluggable garbage collectors, and parallel multithreading which makes it suitable for multicore applications. One thing I think sets JRuby apart is that it's the most mature language on the JVM which didn't start there. Other projects to implement non-JVM languages on top of the JVM, such as Rhino and Jython, have languished, while JRuby keeps going strong.

The most exciting development in JRuby is Java 7's new InvokeDynamic feature. The Java Virtual Machine was originally designed for the statically-typed Java language, but has its roots in dynamic languages, namely Smalltalk. With InvokeDynamic, the JVM has come full circle and now natively supports dynamic languages like Ruby. InvokeDynamic provides the necessary information to the JVM's HotSpot compiler to generate clean native code whenever Ruby methods are called, in addition to many other potential optimizations. So how much faster will InvokeDynamic make Ruby?


Rubinius, a clean-room Ruby virtual machine based on the Smalltalk-80 architecture, is also a very exciting prospect for the Ruby community as it matures and reaches production quality. It features an LLVM-based JIT compiler, parallel thread execution, and advanced garbage collection, also making it suitable for multicore applications. Beyond being an awesome Ruby implementation, Rubinius has evolved into a true polyglot platform and now features multiple Rubinius-specific language implementations including Fancy and Atomy.

MacRuby also eliminated the GIL from their implementation and now supports parallel thread execution along with an LLVM-based JIT compiler.

There are no less than three Ruby implementations which now support thread-level parallelism and thus multicore CPUs. This is especially relevant in a time when computing is undergoing a sort of phase transition from single-threaded sequential applications to massively multithreaded concurrent applications and distributed systems made out of these multithreaded applications.

It wasn't too long ago that having even four CPU cores in your home computer seemed like a lot, and now 16-core commodity AMD CPUs are available. The future is multicore, and if your programming language doesn't have a multicore strategy, its usefulness is vanishing. Following Moore's Law, the number of cores in a CPU is set to explode exponentially. Is your programming language prepared?

Thanks to JRuby and Rubinius, Ruby can take advantage of multicore CPUs. This still leaves the small matter that multithreaded programming is, uhh, hard. Fortunately I have some ideas about that.

Celluloid is an actor-based concurrent object system that tries to pick up on the concurrent object research that was hot in the mid-90's but died shortly after the web gained popularity. In the '90s concurrent objects were ahead of their time, but with the advent of massively multicore CPUs I believe it's an area of computer science research that's worth reviving.

Celluloid packages up Ruby's core concurrency features into a simple, easy-to-use package that doesn't require any modifications to the language. Where many functional languages solve the issues surrounding concurrency with immutable state, Celluloid solves it with encapsulation (more information is available on the Celluloid github page).

Celluloid takes advantage of many of the features of Ruby, including parallel threads, fibers (coroutines), method_missing (proxy objects), and duck typing. There aren't many other languages with this particular mix of features. Python probably comes the closest, aside from multicore execution due to its GIL. Jython supports parallel thread execution thanks to the JVM but seems abandoned. For what it's worth, Python once had a concurrent object system quite similar to Celluloid back in the '90s called ATOM, unfortunately the source code has been lost.

Ruby is by far the best language available today to implement a system like Celluloid, and that alone makes me excited to be a Rubyist. Where Node.js gives you a hammer, the single-threaded event loop, Celluloid gives you a large toolbox and provides a singular framework of interoperable components which can be used to build arbitrary hybrids of concurrent multithreaded applications, event-based nonblocking applications (that are callback-free!), and distributed systems.

Ruby is a language which can survive the massively multicore future. Whether Node will stick around remains to be seen.

710 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   601 – 710 of 710
Tanika Co Valda said...

Great Article. Thank you for sharing! Really an awesome post for every one.
Project Centers in Chennai

JavaScript Training in Chennai

Final Year Project Domains for IT

JavaScript Training in Chennai

Softgen Infotech said...

Thank you so much for the great and very beneficial stuff that you have shared with the world.

Become an Expert In Python Training! The most trusted and trending Programming Language. Learn from experienced Trainers and get the knowledge to crack a coding interview, @Softgen Infotech Located in BTM Layout.

Softgen Infotech said...

Really very happy to say, your post is very interesting to read. I never stop myself to say something about it. You’re doing a great job. Keep it up...

Upgrade your career Learn AWS Training from industry experts get Complete hands-on Training, Interview preparation, and Job Assistance at Softgen Infotech Located in BTM Layout.

Softgen Infotech said...

Enjoyed reading the article above, really explains everything in detail,the article is very interesting and effective.Thank you and good luck…

Start your journey with DevOps Course and get hands-on Experience with 100% Placement assistance from experts Trainers @Softgen Infotech Located in BTM Layout Bangalore.

Bangalore Training Academy said...

I think this is one of the most significant information for me. And i’m glad reading your article. Thanks for sharing!

Bangalore Training Academy have the best Data Warehousing Training in Bangalore . Any professional who is looking out to switch their career can enroll with us.

Real Time Experts said...

Usually I never comment on blogs but your article is so convincing that I never stop myself to say something about it. You’re doing a great job, Keep it up.

Real Time Experts offers the Best SAP SCM Training in Bangalore - Marathahalli, We offer Real-Time Training with Live Projects, Our SAP SCM Trainers are Working Professionals with 8+ years of Expertise in SAP SCM, we also provide placement assistance.

Jackie Co Kad said...

The development of artificial intelligence (AI) has propelled more programming architects, information scientists, and different experts to investigate the plausibility of a vocation in machine learning. Notwithstanding, a few newcomers will in general spotlight a lot on hypothesis and insufficient on commonsense application. IEEE final year projects on machine learning In case you will succeed, you have to begin building machine learning projects in the near future.

Projects assist you with improving your applied ML skills rapidly while allowing you to investigate an intriguing point. Furthermore, you can include projects into your portfolio, making it simpler to get a vocation, discover cool profession openings, and Final Year Project Centers in Chennai even arrange a more significant compensation.


Data analytics is the study of dissecting crude data so as to make decisions about that data. Data analytics advances and procedures are generally utilized in business ventures to empower associations to settle on progressively Python Training in Chennai educated business choices. In the present worldwide commercial center, it isn't sufficient to assemble data and do the math; you should realize how to apply that data to genuine situations such that will affect conduct. In the program you will initially gain proficiency with the specialized skills, including R and Python dialects most usually utilized in data analytics programming and usage; Python Training in Chennai at that point center around the commonsense application, in view of genuine business issues in a scope of industry segments, for example, wellbeing, promoting and account.

svrtechnologies said...

Thanks for Sharing Such an Useful Info...

oracle apex training

sasi said...

This was an excellent post and very good information provided, Thanks for sharing.
Python Training in Chennai
Python training in Bangalore
Python Training in Coimbatore
Python course in Chennai
Big Data Training in Bangalore
python training in hyderabad
python course in bangalore
Python Classes in coimbatore

Jack sparrow said...

Useful information.I am actual blessed to read this article.thanks for giving us this advantageous information.I acknowledge this post.and I would like bookmark this post. Hope more articles from you. i also want to share about the oracle weblogic tutorial with free Bundle videos.

Midnight Partner said...

Best and Top Interior Designers in Gurgaon If you are confounded? Try not to stress. We offer a free conference to help you in settling on a choice with the best vision and quality that you merit.
Best Interior Designers In Gurgaon
Best Interior Designers In Delhi
interiors designing company in gurgaon
interior design company in gurgaon
interior designer in gurgaon
interior designers in gurgaon
interiors designing company in delhi
interior design company in delhi
interior designer in delhi
interior designers in delhi
interior designer delhi
top interior designers in gurgaon
interiors company in gurgaon
top interior decorators in gurgaon
interior designers and decorators in gurgaon
modular office furniture in gurgaon
modular kitchen manufacturers in gurgaon
office furniture in gurgaon
home furniture manufacturer in gurgaon
wooden modular almirah manufacturer in gurgaon
wooden partition manufacturers in gurgaon
false ceiling manufacturer in gurgaon
greed false ceiling manufacturer in gurgaon

Rajesh said...

Nice infromation
Selenium Training In Chennai
Selenium course in chennai
Selenium Training
Selenium Training institute In Chennai
Best Selenium Training in chennai
Selenium Training In Chennai

Rajesh said...

Rpa Training in Chennai
Rpa Course in Chennai
Rpa training institute in Chennai
Best Rpa Course in Chennai
uipath Training in Chennai
Blue prism training in Chennai

Rajesh said...

Data Science Training In Chennai
Data Science Course In Chennai
Data Science Training institute In Chennai
Best Data Science Training In Chennai


Python Training In Chennai
Python course In Chennai
Protractor Training in Chennai
jmeter training in chennai
Loadrunner training in chennai

المتوكل على الله said...



شركة تنظيف مكيفات بالرياض
شركة تنظيف شقق بالرياض
شركة تنظيف مجالس بالرياض
شركة تنظيف موكيت بالرياض
شركة تنظيف واجهات بالرياض

eTechno Soft Solutions said...

Nice post. Thank you for posting something like this...

Enrol in SAP FICO Training in Bangalore to master configurations of H SAP FICO with eTechno Soft Solutions Located in BTM Layout.

vijay said...

Thanks for sharing valuable information.
aws Training in Bangalore
python Training in Bangalore
hadoop Training in Bangalore
angular js Training in Bangalore
bigdata analytics Training in Bangalore
python Training in Bangalore
aws Training in Bangalore

phautecouture said...

Panache Haute Couture, a leading Indian Designer House for Indian Dresses. You can Buy Designer indian wedding dresses lehenga dresses, anarkali suits, indo western bridal gowns,
lehenga choli online, Designer Sarees Online at Online.

lehenga choli


lehenga online

Softgen Infotech said...

Such great information for blogger iam a professional blogger thanks…

Upgrade your career Learn DevOps Training from industry experts gets complete hands on Training, Interview preparation, and Job Assistance at Softgen Infotech.

Savanah Eden said...

its really amazing, keep touch with us
Linkedin Marketing company in india
Erp software development company in india
seo company in india
Wordpress web development company in india
CRM software development company in india

eTechno Soft Solutions said...

wonderful thanks for sharing an amazing idea. keep it...

Looking for SAP HR HCM Training in Bangalore , learn from eTechno Soft Solutions SAP HR HCM Training on online training and classroom training. Join today!

Rahul Aniket said...

7starhd movies

angelisaka97 said...

Deposit Poker Pakai pulsa

deposit idn poker pakai pulsa

deposit idn poker 77 pakai pulsa

deposit poker 77 pakai pulsa

deposit idn poker 77 via pulsa

idn poker 77 deposit pulsa

poker 77 deposit pulsa

poker 77 deposit pakai pulsa


Daftar IDN Poker

Daftar IDN poker online

daftar idn poker 77

idn poker 77

daftar akun idn poker 77

daftar poker 77

cara daftar idn poker 77

cara daftar poker 77


Deposit IDN Poker

deposit poker 77

deposit poker77

cara deposit poker 77

cara deposit IDN Poker 77

Deposit IDN Poker 77

deposit poker online 77

cara deposit poker online 77


login IDN Poker

login poker 77

login IDN Poker 77


IDN Poker APK

Download IDN Poker APK

IDN Poker APK versi baru

idn poker 77 apk

apk idn poker 77

aplikasi poker 77

aplikasi idn poker 77

download idn poker 77 apk

phautecouture said...

Panache Haute Couture, a leading Indian Designer House for Indian Dresses. You can Buy Designer indian wedding dresses lehenga dresses, anarkali suits, indo western bridal gowns,
lehenga choli online, Designer Sarees Online at Online.

lehenga choli


lehenga online

Servo said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Servo said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Rajesh said...

Nice infromation
Selenium Training In Chennai
Selenium course in chennai
Selenium Training
Selenium Training institute In Chennai
Best Selenium Training in chennai
Selenium Training In Chennai

Rajesh said...

Rpa Training in Chennai
Rpa Course in Chennai
Rpa training institute in Chennai
Best Rpa Course in Chennai
uipath Training in Chennai
Blue prism training in Chennai

Rajesh said...

Data Science Training In Chennai
Data Science Course In Chennai
Data Science Training institute In Chennai
Best Data Science Training In Chennai


Python Training In Chennai
Python course In Chennai
Protractor Training in Chennai
jmeter training in chennai
Loadrunner training in chennai

joyhopson.07 said...

Shifting a house is start with looking through the pleasant Packers and Movers Delhi thru the different mode,
for instance, indexes, web index Google, or getting alluded by partners.
||Packers And Movers In Delhi NCR
||Delhi Packers and Movers
||best packers and movers in delhi ncr
||packers and movers cost in delhi ncr
||top packers and movers in delhi ncr
||delhi ncr packers and movers
||office relocation delhi ncr
||household relocation delhi ncr
||corporate goods relocation delhi ncr
||professional packers and movers in delhi ncr
||top packers in delhi ncr
||packers and movers delhi ncr
||best packers and movers in hisar
||best packers and movers in narwana
||best packers and movers in fatehabad
||best packers and movers in sonipat
||best packers and movers in jind
||best packers and movers in kriti nagar
||best packers and movers in sirsa
||best packers and movers in dabwali
||best packers and movers in bahadurgarh
||best packers and movers in bhiwani
||best packers and movers in rohini
||best packers and movers in punjabi bagh
||best packers and movers in nangloi
||best packers and movers in kaithal
||best packers and movers in uttam nagar
||packers and movers near me
||movers and packers rates in delhi ncr
||trusted packers and movers in delhi ncr

Midnight Partner said...

Spaces Interiors prime spotlight is on giving the prevalent assistance of inside planning. The structuring for any sort of room can make an air or make an impression of their way of life.
||Best Modular Office Furniture in Gurgaon
||modular furniture manufacturerin gurgaon
||office furniture manufacturer in gurgaon
||office chair manufacturer in gurgaon
||modular furniture manufacturer in delhi
||office furniture manufacturer in delhi
||modular kitchens in gurgaon
||modular kitchen in delhi
||designer kitchens in gurgaon
||kitchen interior in gurgaon
||luxury kitchens in gurgaon
||Best Office Furniture In Gurgaon & Delhi
||office furniture in gurgaon
||office furniture in delhi
||school furniture in gurgaon
||office furniture services in delhi
||Best Home Furniture Manufacturer in Gurgaon & Delhi
||home furniture in delhi
||home furniture in gurgaon
||living room furniture in gurgaon
||bedroom furniture in gurgaon
||living room furniture in delhi

Dream11 Teams said...

Hair transplant treatment cost
Hair transplant doctor

Dream11 Teams said...

We also provide Best Australia Immigration consultant in Hyderabad and Best Canada Immigration Consultants in Hyderabad, Best immigration consultants in Hyderabad.We also Provide Best Australia Immigration consultants in Bangalore, Best Canada Immigration consultants in Bangalore, Best Immigration Consultants in Bangalore and best australian immigration consultants in chandigarh, best Canada immigration consultants in chandigarh, best australian immigration consultants in mumbai, and best canada immigration consultants in mumbai

Dream11 Teams said...

Dream11 Team Prediction Today Tips main focus is to provide Dream11 team for today match, Dream11 prediction Today, Dream11 tips and prediction, Fantasy cricket tips, today match prediction tips, and today ipl match prediction for all cricket matches.

Dream11 Teams said...

Hair transplant treatment cost
Hair transplant doctor

Dream11 Teams said...

We also provide Best Australia Immigration consultant in Hyderabad and Best Canada Immigration Consultants in Hyderabad, Best immigration consultants in Hyderabad.We also Provide Best Australia Immigration consultants in Bangalore, Best Canada Immigration consultants in Bangalore, Best Immigration Consultants in Bangalore and best australian immigration consultants in chandigarh, best Canada immigration consultants in chandigarh, best australian immigration consultants in mumbai, and best canada immigration consultants in mumbai

Dream11 Teams said...

Dream11 Team Prediction Today Tips main focus is to provide Dream11 team for today match, Dream11 prediction Today, Dream11 tips and prediction, Fantasy cricket tips, today match prediction tips, and today ipl match prediction for all cricket matches.

Dream11 Teams said...

Dream11 Team Prediction Today Tips main focus is to provide Dream11 team for today match, Dream11 prediction Today, Dream11 tips and prediction, Fantasy cricket tips, today match prediction tips, and today ipl match prediction for all cricket matches.

Dream11 Teams said...

We also provide Best Australia Immigration consultant in Hyderabad and Best Canada Immigration Consultants in Hyderabad, Best immigration consultants in Hyderabad.We also Provide Best Australia Immigration consultants in Bangalore, Best Canada Immigration consultants in Bangalore, Best Immigration Consultants in Bangalore and best australian immigration consultants in chandigarh, best Canada immigration consultants in chandigarh, best australian immigration consultants in mumbai, and best canada immigration consultants in mumbai

Dream11 Teams said...

Hair transplant treatment cost
Hair transplant doctor

Dream11 Teams said...

Dream11 Team Prediction Today Tips main focus is to provide Dream11 team for today match, Dream11 prediction Today, Dream11 tips and prediction, Fantasy cricket tips, today match prediction tips, and today ipl match prediction for all cricket matches.

Dream11 Teams said...

We also provide Best Australia Immigration consultant in Hyderabad and Best Canada Immigration Consultants in Hyderabad, Best immigration consultants in Hyderabad.We also Provide Best Australia Immigration consultants in Bangalore, Best Canada Immigration consultants in Bangalore, Best Immigration Consultants in Bangalore and best australian immigration consultants in chandigarh, best Canada immigration consultants in chandigarh, best australian immigration consultants in mumbai, and best canada immigration consultants in mumbai

Dream11 Teams said...

Hair transplant treatment cost
Hair transplant doctor

Dream11 Teams said...

We also provide Best Australia Immigration consultant in Hyderabad and Best Canada Immigration Consultants in Hyderabad, Best immigration consultants in Hyderabad.We also Provide Best Australia Immigration consultants in Bangalore, Best Canada Immigration consultants in Bangalore, Best Immigration Consultants in Bangalore and best australian immigration consultants in chandigarh, best Canada immigration consultants in chandigarh, best australian immigration consultants in mumbai, and best canada immigration consultants in mumbai

Dream11 Teams said...

Dream11 Team Prediction Today Tips main focus is to provide Dream11 team for today match, Dream11 prediction Today, Dream11 tips and prediction, Fantasy cricket tips, today match prediction tips, and today ipl match prediction for all cricket matches.

Dream11 Teams said...

We also provide Best Australia Immigration consultant in Hyderabad and Best Canada Immigration Consultants in Hyderabad, Best immigration consultants in Hyderabad.We also Provide Best Australia Immigration consultants in Bangalore, Best Canada Immigration consultants in Bangalore, Best Immigration Consultants in Bangalore and best australian immigration consultants in chandigarh, best Canada immigration consultants in chandigarh, best australian immigration consultants in mumbai, and best canada immigration consultants in mumbai

Dream11 Teams said...

Hair transplant treatment cost
Hair transplant doctor

Dream11 Teams said...

We also provide Best Australia Immigration consultant in Hyderabad and Best Canada Immigration Consultants in Hyderabad, Best immigration consultants in Hyderabad.We also Provide Best Australia Immigration consultants in Bangalore, Best Canada Immigration consultants in Bangalore, Best Immigration Consultants in Bangalore and best australian immigration consultants in chandigarh, best Canada immigration consultants in chandigarh, best australian immigration consultants in mumbai, and best canada immigration consultants in mumbai

Dream11 Teams said...

Dream11 Team Prediction Today Tips main focus is to provide Dream11 team for today match, Dream11 prediction Today, Dream11 tips and prediction, Fantasy cricket tips, today match prediction tips, and today ipl match prediction for all cricket matches.

Tania Febriana said...

Permainan tembak ikan adalah permainan yang paling rame orang mainkan, apalagi jika pelayanannya yang sangat memuaskan bagi anda tentunya kalian pasti akan merasa sangat puas juga kan ?, bagi kalian yang sangat menyukai permainan tembak ikan bisa datang ke situs kami :)

TEMBAK IKAN JOKER123

judi tembak ikan joker123

daftar akun tembak ikan joker123


DAFTAR AKUN TEMBAK IKAN JOKER123

daftar game tembak ikan joker123

daftar slot joker123

game tembak ikan


LOGIN TEMBAK IKAN JOKER123


DEPOSIT PULSA TEMBAK IKAN


DOWNLOAD APLIKASI JOKER123 APK


aplikasi joker123 apk

aplikasi joker123 apk android

aplikasi joker123 apk ios

aplikasi joker123 ios

daftar akun tembak ikan joker123

link alternatif joker123 apk

Unknown said...

Are you looking to hire Chennai Escort girls, Browse Chennai-escorts.net and book your choice based escort to enjoy full night.
Escorts Chennai

Customer relationship management said...

Its really helpful for the users of this site. I am also searching about these type of sites now a days. So your site really helps me for searching the new and great stuff.

sap s4 hana training in bangalore

sap simplefinance training in bangalore

sap training in bangalore

sap abap training in bangalore

sap basis training in bangalore

sap bi training in bangalore

sap dynpro training in bangalore

sap fico training in bangalore

Customer relationship management said...

This is the exact information I am been searching for, Thanks for sharing the required infos with the clear update and required points. To appreciate this I like to share some useful information.

sap crm training in bangalore

sap ehs training in bangalore

sap bw training in bangalore

sap hana training in bangalore

sap hr training in bangalore

sap mm training in bangalore

sap pm training in bangalore

sap pp training in bangalore

Customer relationship management said...

It is very good and useful for students and developer.Learned a lot of new things from your post Good creation,thanks for give a good information.

sap ps training in bangalore

sap qm training in bangalore

sap scm training in bangalore

sap sd training in bangalore

sap srm training in bangalore

sap hybris training in bangalore

sap wm training in bangalore

sap ewm training in bangalore

Customer relationship management said...

I have to voice my passion for your kindness giving support to those people that should have guidance on this important matter.

sap solution manager training in bangalore

sap security training in bangalore

sap grc security training in bangalore

sap ui5 training in bangalore

sap bods training in bangalore

sap apo training in bangalore

sap gts training in bangalore

sap hana admin training in bangalore

Customer relationship management said...

Excellent post for the people who really need information for this technology.

sap idm training in bangalore

sap mdm training in bangalore

sap successfactor training in bangalore

sap fiori training in bangalore

sap bpc training in bangalore

sap testing training in bangalore

sap testing training in bangalore

sap simple logistics training in bangalore

watson said...

Thanks for one marvelous posting! I enjoyed reading it; you are a great author. I will make sure to bookmark your blog and may come back someday. I want to encourage that you continue your great posts.

sap hybris training in bangalore

sap scm training in bangalore

sap pm training in bangalore

sap crm training in bangalore

sap ewm training in bangalore

watson said...

Thank you for your post. This is excellent information. It is amazing and wonderful to visit your site.

SAP PP Training in Bangalore

sap s4 hana training in bangalore

sap bw training in bangalore

sap sd training in bangalore

sap hr training in bangalore

watson said...

Thanks for sharing this blog. This very important and informative blog

sap basis training in bangalore

sap mm training in bangalore

sap hana training in bangalore

sap fico training in bangalore

sap abap training in bangalore

watson said...

Thank you for your post. This is excellent information. It is amazing and wonderful to visit your site.

sap ehs training in bangalore

sap ps training in bangalore

SAP SRM Training in Bangalore

sap wm training in bangalore

sap security training in bangalore

watson said...

Thank you for your post. This is excellent information. It is amazing and wonderful to visit your site.

sap ehs training in bangalore

sap ps training in bangalore

SAP SRM Training in Bangalore

sap wm training in bangalore

sap security training in bangalore

Durai Moorthy said...

This is an awesome blog. Really very informative and creative contents.

aws Training in Bangalore
python Training in Bangalore
hadoop Training in Bangalore
angular js Training in Bangalore
bigdata analytics Training in Bangalore
python Training in Bangalore
aws Training in Bangalore

shalini said...

Excellent information with unique content and it is very useful to know about the information based on blogs..
spoken english classes in bangalore
Spoken English Classes in Chennai
spoken english class in coimbatore
spoken english class in madurai
aws training in bangalore
Data Science Courses in Bangalore
english speaking course in bangalore
Best Spoken English Classes in Chennai
best spoken english class in coimbatore
best spoken english class in madurai

sasi said...

It's a looks very awesome article! Thanks a lot of sharing for information.
Python course in Chennai
Python Training in Bangalore
Python Course in Coimbatore
Python Training in Chennai
Big Data Training in Coimbatore
Salesforce Training in Bangalore
Python Classes in Bangalore
python training in hyderabad

Johan said...

I must appreciate you for providing such a valuable content for us. This is one amazing piece of article. Helped a lot in increasing my knowledge.

oracle training in bangalore

oracle courses in bangalore

oracle classes in bangalore

oracle training institute in bangalore

oracle course syllabus

best oracle training

oracle training centers

Johan said...

Thanks for this. I really like what you've posted here and wish you the best of luck with this blog and thanks for sharing.

sql server dba training in bangalore

sql server dba courses in bangalore

sql server dba classes in bangalore

sql server dba training institute in bangalore

sql server dba course syllabus

best sql server dba training

sql server dba training centers

Johan said...

Thank you for sharing .The data that you provided in the blog is informative and effective.

web designing training in bangalore

web designing courses in bangalore

web designing classes in bangalore

web designing training institute in bangalore

web designing course syllabus

best web designing training

web designing training centers

Johan said...

This is most informative and also this post most user friendly and super navigation to all posts. Thank you so much for giving this information to me.

digital marketing training in bangalore

digital marketing courses in bangalore

digital marketing classes in bangalore

digital marketing training institute in bangalore

digital marketing course syllabus

best digital marketing training

digital marketing training centers

Johan said...

Thanks for sharing amazing information.Gain the knowledge and hands-on experience.

java training in bangalore

java courses in bangalore

java classes in bangalore

java training institute in bangalore

java course syllabus

best java training

java training centers

Sandra Riyanti said...


Permainan Slot Pussy tentunya banyak kalian yang belum tahu tentang permainan nama slot ini, jika sudah mencoba pastinya kalian lebih memilih permainan slot pussy daripada slot lainnya, karena pussy memiliki permainan slot yang sangat banyak, silahkan kunjungi situs kami untuk mengetahui lebih banyak.

SLOT PUSSY888

agen slot pussy888

agen pussy888 indonesia

download pussy888 apk

aplikasi pussy888

daftar akun pussy888

macauslot88


DAFTAR AKUN PUSSY888 SLOT

daftar akun slot pussy888

slot pussy888 apk

download pussy888 apk

aplikasi pussy888 apk


LOGIN PUSSY888 APK


DEPOSIT SLOT PUSSY888 PULSA


DOWNLOAD PUSSY888 APK

aplikasi slot pussy888 apk

download pussy888 apk android dan ios

aplikasi slot pussy888 apk ios

daftar akun pussy888 slot


LIVECHAT SLOT PUSSY888

Cherry said...

Thanks for sharing such awesome blog post, I appreciate your efforts for spreading useful information.

https://dailygram.com/index.php/profile-307499
https://brooklynne.net/profile/GoogleAdultSEO
https://downtownmiami.com/profile/jamescherry262
https://bibliocrunch.com/profile/googleadultseo/
http://www.czechtribe.com/profile/61833
https://pbase.com/googleadultseo/profile
https://triberr.com/googleadultseo

Midnight Partner said...

Best and Top Interior Designers in Gurgaon If you are confounded? Try not to stress. We offer a free conference to help you in settling on a choice with the best vision and quality that you merit.
||Best Interior Designers In Gurgaon & Delhi
||Spaces Interior
||interiors designing company in gurgaon
||best interior designers in gurgaon
||wooden partition in gurgaon
||wooden partition gurgaon
||wooden partition manufacturer in gurgaon
||wooden partition in delhi
||false ceiling services in gurgaon
||false ceiling services gurgaon
||false ceiling services delhi
||false ceiling services in delhi
||greed false ceiling services in gurgaon
||greed false ceiling services delhi
||greed false ceiling manufacturer in gurgaon
||greed false ceiling manufacturer in delhi

Bangalore Training Academy said...

Enjoyed reading the article above, really explains everything in detail, the article is very interesting and effective. Thank you and good luck…

Hadoop Training in Bangalore
Hadoop Courses in Bangalore
Hadoop Classes in Bangalore
Hadoop Training Institute in Bangalore
Hadoop Course Syllabus
Best Hadoop Training
Hadoop Training Centers

Bangalore Training Academy said...

Really very happy to say, your post is very interesting to read. I never stop myself to say something about it. You’re doing a great job. Keep it up...

Big Data Analytics Training in Bangalore
Big Data Analytics Courses in Bangalore
Big Data Analytics Classes in Bangalore
Big Data Analytics Training Institute in Bangalore
Big Data Analytics Course Syllabus
Best Big Data Analytics Training
Big Data Analytics Training Centers

Bangalore Training Academy said...

I think this is one of the most significant information for me. And I’m glad reading your article. Thanks for sharing!

Tableau Training in Bangalore
Tableau Courses in Bangalore
Tableau Classes in Bangalore
Tableau Training Institute in Bangalore
Tableau Course Syllabus
Best Tableau Training
Tableau Training Centers

Bangalore Training Academy said...

It’s really great information for becoming a better Blogger. Keep sharing, Thanks...

Data Science Training in Bangalore
Data Science Courses in Bangalore
Data Science Classes in Bangalore
Data Science Training Institute in Bangalore
Data Science Course Syllabus
Best Data Science Training
Data Science Training Centers

Bangalore Training Academy said...

Thank you so much for the great and very beneficial stuff that you have shared with the world.

Workday Training in Bangalore
Workday Courses in Bangalore
Workday Classes in Bangalore
Workday Training Institute in Bangalore
Workday Course Syllabus
Best Workday Training
Workday Training Centers

Johan said...

I must appreciate you for providing such a valuable content for us. This is one amazing piece of article. Helped a lot in increasing my knowledge.

oracle training in bangalore

oracle courses in bangalore

oracle classes in bangalore

oracle training institute in bangalore

oracle course syllabus

best oracle training

oracle training centers

Johan said...

Thanks for this. I really like what you've posted here and wish you the best of luck with this blog and thanks for sharing.

sql server dba training in bangalore

sql server dba courses in bangalore

sql server dba classes in bangalore

sql server dba training institute in bangalore

sql server dba course syllabus

best sql server dba training

sql server dba training centers

Johan said...

Thank you for sharing .The data that you provided in the blog is informative and effective.

web designing training in bangalore

web designing courses in bangalore

web designing classes in bangalore

web designing training institute in bangalore

web designing course syllabus

best web designing training

web designing training centers

Johan said...

This is most informative and also this post most user friendly and super navigation to all posts. Thank you so much for giving this information to me.

digital marketing training in bangalore

digital marketing courses in bangalore

digital marketing classes in bangalore

digital marketing training institute in bangalore

digital marketing course syllabus

best digital marketing training

digital marketing training centers

Johan said...

Thanks for sharing amazing information.Gain the knowledge and hands-on experience.

java training in bangalore

java courses in bangalore

java classes in bangalore

java training institute in bangalore

java course syllabus

best java training

java training centers

watson said...

Great post!I am actually getting ready to across this information,i am very happy to this commands.Also great blog here with all of the valuable information you have.Well done,its a great knowledge.

sap abap training in bangalore

sap abap courses in bangalore

sap abap classes in bangalore

sap abap course syllabus

best sap abap training

sap abap training center

sap abap training institute in bangalore

watson said...


It is amazing and wonderful to visit your site.Thanks for sharing this information,this is useful

sap hana courses in bangalore

sap hana classes in bangalore

sap hana training institute in bangalore

sap hana course syllabus

best sap hana training

sap hana training centers

best sap hana training

watson said...

Great post!I am actually getting ready to across this information,i am very happy to this commands.Also great blog here with all of the valuable information you have.Well done,its a great knowledge.

sap hr courses in bangalore

sap hr classes in bangalore

sap hr training institute in bangalore

sap hr course syllabus

best sap hr training

sap hr training centers

sap hr training in bangalore

watson said...

Thank you for your post. This is excellent information. It is amazing and wonderful to visit your site.

sap mm training in bangalore

sap mm courses in bangalore

sap mm classes in bangalore

sap mm training institute in bangalore

sap mm course syllabus

best sap mm training

sap mm training centers

watson said...

Learned a lot of new things from your post! Good creation and HATS OFF to the creativity of your mind

sap fico training in bangalore

sap fico courses in bangalore

sap fico classes in bangalore

sap fico training institute in bangalore

sap fico course syllabus

best sap fico training

sap fico training centers

Customer relationship management said...

Its really helpful for the users of this site. I am also searching about these type of sites now a days. So your site really helps me for searching the new and great stuff.

aws training in bangalore

aws courses in bangalore

aws classes in bangalore

aws training institute in bangalore

aws course syllabus

best aws training

aws training centers

Customer relationship management said...

This is the exact information I am been searching for, Thanks for sharing the required infos with the clear update and required points. To appreciate this I like to share some useful information.

mulesoft training in bangalore

mulesoft courses in bangalore

mulesoft classes in bangalore

mulesoft training institute in bangalore

mulesoft course syllabus

best mulesoft training

mulesoft training centers

Customer relationship management said...

It is very good and useful for students and developer.Learned a lot of new things from your post Good creation,thanks for give a good information.

salesforce developer training in bangalore

salesforce developer courses in bangalore

salesforce developer classes in bangalore

salesforce developer training institute in bangalore

salesforce developer course syllabus

best salesforce developer training

salesforce developer training centers

Customer relationship management said...

I have to voice my passion for your kindness giving support to those people that should have guidance on this important matter.

salesforce admin training in bangalore

salesforce admin courses in bangalore

salesforce admin classes in bangalore

salesforce admin training institute in bangalore

salesforce admin course syllabus

best salesforce admin training

salesforce admin training centers

Customer relationship management said...

Excellent post for the people who really need information for this technology.

servicenow training in bangalore

servicenow courses in bangalore

servicenow classes in bangalore

servicenow training institute in bangalore

servicenow course syllabus

servicenow course syllabus

servicenow training centers

Customer relationship management said...

Very useful and information content has been shared out here, Thanks for sharing it.

cloud computing training in bangalore

cloud computing courses in bangalore

cloud computing classes in bangalore

cloud computing training institute in bangalore

cloud computing course syllabus

best cloud computing training

cloud computing training centers

Customer relationship management said...

Awesome post with lots of data and I have bookmarked this page for my reference. Share more ideas frequently.

dell boomi training in bangalore

dell boomi courses in bangalore

dell boomi classes in bangalore

dell boomi training institute in bangalore

dell boomi course syllabus

best dell boomi training

dell boomi training centers

joyhopson.07 said...



||Packers And Movers In Nangloi
||Nangloi Packers And Movers
||Packers And Movers In Rohtak
||Rohtak Packers And Movers
||Packers And Movers In Jhajjar
||Jhajjar Packers And Movers
||Best Packers And Movers In Hansi
||Hansi Packers And Movers
||Packers And Movers In Mundka
||Mundka Packers And Movers
||Packers And Movers In Kaithal
||Kaithal Packers And Movers
||Packers And Movers In Uttam Nagar
||Packers Movers Near Me

rightselects said...

Thanks for posting such a great post . Right Selects provides its users with the exact information of the “top 10” or “top 5” industry leader of the particular industry. For instance, if you are looking for selecting the best among the array of water purifiers in india , you can visit us for getting the most accurate information about “Top 10 water purifier for home”. Additionally, at right selects, you can have the information on lifestyle products, electronics, appliances, water purifiers, restaurants as well as about the best travel places.

Unknown said...

Thanks for sharing this wonderful article.
East Nigeria

sindhuvarun said...

Thanks for taking time to share this useful blog...
DOT NET Training in Chennai
DOT NET Training in Bangalore
.Net training in chennai
best dot net training institutes in bangalore
aws training in bangalore
Data Science Courses in Bangalore
DevOps Training in Bangalore
PHP Training in bangalore
spoken english classes in bangalore
DOT NET Course in Chennai

Venkatesh CS said...

Thanks for sharing valuable information.
Digital Marketing training Course in Chennai
digital marketing training institute in Chennai
digital marketing training in Chennai
digital marketing course in Chennai
digital marketing course training in omr
digital marketing certification in omr
digital marketing course training in velachery
digital marketing training center in Chennai
digital marketing courses with placement in Chennai
digital marketing certification in Chennai
digital marketing institute in Chennai
digital marketing certification course in Chennai
digital marketing course training in Chennai
Digital Marketing course in Chennai with placement

infotech Zone 93 said...

Infotech Zone - Best Web Design, Best Web Development, Best Digital Marketing Company in Ludhiana, Punjab

Top Rated Best Graphic Designing, Best Web Design, Best Web Development and Best Digital Marketing Company in Ludhiana, Punjab

Top Rated SEO, SMO, Web Design and Digital Marketing Company in Ludhiana, Punjab

infotech Zone 93 said...

Wedding DJ, Photo Booth and Karaoke - Caught in the Act Entertainment in Eugene, Lane County, Oregon

Photo Booth - Caught in the Act Entertainment in Eugene, Lane County, Oregon

DJ, Photo Booth, Karaoke and Party Rentals - Caught in the Act Entertainment in Eugene, Lane County, Oregon

Karaoke and Event DJ - Caught in the Act Entertainment in Eugene, Lane County, Oregon

Online Booking - Best Wedding DJ, Event DJ, Birthday DJ, Party Rentals, Photo Booth and Karaoke in Eugene, Lane County, Oregon

Caught in the Act Entertainment - Wedding DJ, Event DJ, Birthday DJ, Photo Booth and Karaoke in Eugene, Lane County, Oregon

infotech Zone 93 said...

Top Rated, Leading Finance Assessment Company in Eugene, Oregon
CSK Dynamic Ventures LLC in Eugene, Oregon
Contact CSK Dynamic Ventures LLC in Eugene, Oregon
Business ventures in oregon
US Finance Venture Company in oregon
Finance Venture Company in oregon

Parul said...

Good Blog...Thanks for sharing..
CBSE school in Dehradun
Top School in Dehradun
Dehradun Famous School
Best school in Dehradun fees
Day Schools in Dehradun

Jack sparrow said...



I am really happy to say it’s an interesting post to read . I learn new information from your article , you are doing a great job . Keep it up and a i also want to share some information regarding selenium training course and selenium videos


Barrister Babu said...

Barrister Babu is a Hindi language Indian Television serial on
Colors TV of 2020. This tv serial features Madhushree Sharma

Barrister Babu

Shadeep Shree said...

Fantastic blog!!! Thanks for sharing with us, Waiting for your upcoming data.
Digital Marketing Course in Chennai
Digital Marketing Course
digital marketing training institute in chennai
Digital Marketing Training in Chennai
Digital marketing course in Velachery
Digital marketing course in Adyar
Python Training in Chennai
Software testing training in chennai
JAVA Training in Chennai

Reshma said...

Nice blog! Thanks for sharing this valuable information
IELTS Coaching centre in Chennai
IELTS Coaching centre in coimbatore
IELTS Coaching in madurai
IELTS Coaching in Bangalore
IELTS Coaching in Hyderabad
IELTS Coaching in coimbatore
IELTS Training coimbatore
IELTS Classes in coimbatore
Software Testing Course in Bangalore

Mahzar said...

BSc Cardiac Care Technology – Here is the details about Best BSc Cardiac Care Technology Colleges In Bangalore. If you are looking to study in Bangalore, the below link will redirect to a page that will show the best BCC colleges in Bangalore
BSc Cardiac Care Technology Colleges In Bangalore

Mahzar said...

BSc in Optometry – Here is the details about Best BSc Optometry Colleges In Bangalore. If you are looking to study in Bangalore, the below link will redirect to a page that will show the best OPT colleges in Bangalore. If you are looking to study BSc Optometry in Bangalore, click the below link.
Optometry Colleges In Bangalore

Mahzar said...

GrueBleen – One of the best branding and marketing agency in Riyadh- Saudi Arabia. If you need the details, click the below link
Branding Agency Riyadh
Marketing Agency Riyadh

«Oldest ‹Older   601 – 710 of 710   Newer› Newest»